Toronto Maple Leafs Linked to Columbus Blue Jackets Star Zach Werenski Amid Trade Speculation

Zach Werenski #8 of the Columbus Blue Jackets controls the puck during the first period against the Washington Capitals at Nationwide Arena on April 14, 2026 in Columbus, Ohio. (Photo by Jason Mowry/Getty Images)

As NHL trade speculation heats up ahead of the new season, the Toronto Maple Leafs are among the teams most frequently linked to Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman Zach Werenski. Sources say the league’s current Norris Trophy holder is drawing a lot of interest around the league with questions about his long-term future in Columbus. Werenski's elite production from the blue line and his close relationship with Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews have only fueled speculation about a potential move. But, to land one of the league's best blueliners, Toronto would probably have to give up some premium pieces.

Toronto Maple Leafs pursue NHL trade Columbus Blue Jackets star Zach Werenski

The Toronto Maple Leafs are looking into the possibility of trading for Zach Werenski, but league analysts believe the asking price could be one of the biggest of the offseason. The Toronto has been looking for a true No. 1 defenseman for several seasons who can impact every situation on the ice. That’s Werenski, coming off a Norris Trophy-winning season where he put up 81 points and 22 goals. His ability to contribute offensively while also manning tough defensive assignments places him among the league’s most valuable blue liners.

CategoryDetailsPlayerZach WerenskiCurrent TeamColumbus Blue JacketsRumored TeamsToronto Maple Leafs, Dallas Stars, Vegas Golden Knights, Philadelphia Flyers, Carolina HurricanesContract StatusSigned through the 2027-28 season with unrestricted free agency eligibility in 2028; contract protection clauses apply during the 2026-27 campaign.Salary Cap Hit (New Team)Approximately $9.58 million AAV against the salary cap.Trade LikelihoodModerate to High; driven by league-wide speculation surrounding his long-term future and the premium value attached to a Norris Trophy-winning defenseman.Key Reason for InterestElite two-way defenseman capable of handling top defensive assignments while producing offensively at an elite level.Maple Leafs ConnectionStrong friendship with Auston Matthews through their time representing the United States men's national ice hockey team in international competition.Latest Insider UpdateAnalysts on TSN's OverDrive described Werenski's price as a "king's ransom," with Toronto expected to face heavy competition if Columbus entertains offers.Potential ReturnColumbus would likely seek NHL-ready roster players, top prospects, and premium draft assets rather than a package centered solely around future picks.Biggest Obstacle for TorontoMatching Columbus' asking price without significantly weakening the Maple Leafs' current roster core.

Why NHL analysts expect a massive trade package

In recent episodes of TSN’s OverDrive, analysts Bryan Hayes and Jeff O’Neill said Werenski’s value is comparable to some of the biggest trade targets in the NHL. Hayes said the reigning Norris Trophy winner would cost a “king’s ransom,” and O’Neill wondered if Toronto has enough assets to actually make that trade right now.

How Auston Matthews could influence the situation

O’Neill also noted the close relationship between Auston Matthews and Werenski during their time with Team USA as something to watch. Both players have represented the United States internationally and remain close off the ice. Player recruitment is more prevalent in the NBA, but some analysts think Matthews could attempt to persuade Werenski that Toronto provides a real opportunity to contend for a Stanley Cup. For now, it seems the Columbus Blue Jackets are focused on getting the most for Werenski’s trade value should they decide to move their franchise defenseman.