RSPCA seeks jail for couple who tortured puppy to death

The RSPCA is pushing for an immediate jail term for a couple who abused and tortured an 11-week-old puppy to death.

WARNING: Readers are advised that this story contains details of animal cruelty,which some people may find distressing.

Nathan James Dekkers and Isabel Maree Busher, both 26, had previously pleaded guilty to more than a dozen animal cruelty charges, including beating and tormenting a puppy, and misleading RSPCA investigators.

The pair were due to be sentenced in the Busselton Magistrates Court on Tuesday, but the case was adjourned for five months after Busher's defence lawyer pushed for a psychiatric report, which was expected to take 20 weeks.

There was a strong police presence outside the courthouse, with a group of 10 protesters yelling at Dekker and Busher as they arrived and departed court.

Trauma history

RSPCA prosecutors Ruby Harris and Ian Wheldon strongly opposed the defence's request, describing it as "clutching at straws."

The animal cruelty charges relate to the abuse of an 11-week-old bull terrier puppy, named Douglas, over several weeks in December 2024.

The couple also pleaded guilty to providing false information to an RSPCA Inspector during a search of their home.

Defence lawyer Michelle Huber told the court the results of a neuropsychological report indicated a further psychiatric assessment was required for Busher.

While mindful of the delay, Ms Huber said the psychological report had noted Busher's history of complex trauma and anxiety.

She said there were concerns about Busher's functional literacy.

'Clutching at straws'

Prosecutors told the court the charges and offenses were so serious that an immediate jail term was required.

RSPCA lawyer Ian Wheldon said he could not see the utility of a psychiatric report.

"It's simply not true there is functional illiteracy … it's clutching at straws," he said.

"There has been ample time to prepare."

Magistrate Stephen Butcher noted the neuropsychological report had offered few mitigating factors for Busher, but he was prepared to order the psychiatric assessment it recommended.

He adjourned the case until October 9, with the couple's bail extended until that date.