Trump's Beijing Visit: Style Over Substance Amidst Wary Stalemate

“American strength back on the world stage,” crowed the White House social media post: a curious remark, when the attached video showed the stars and stripes fluttering beneath a long row of Chinese flags, and People’s Liberation Army soldiers marching in unison.

This week’s visit to Beijing offered the kind of style that Donald Trump enjoys – parading troops, a banquet and a polite if not markedly enthusiastic welcome from a strongman he called “really a friend” – but little apparent substance. The public account of the encounter will be partial: Mr Trump’s former adviser John Bolton has claimed that in previous conversations the US president begged Xi Jinping for help to win re-election and urged him to “go ahead” with internment camps for Uyghurs in Xinjiang. But this meeting appears to have been about stabilising the relationship, not shifting it.

Chaotic US planning for a trip deferred due to the Iran war may have contributed to the lack of tangible outcomes. But the overall impression is of a wary stalemate. Just over a year ago, the US imposed 145% tariffs on China. Beijing hit back with its own tariffs and, critically, curbs on desperately needed rare earths exports, forcing Mr Trump to retreat. The US national security strategy announced a new focus on the western hemisphere. Military assets have been moved from Asia to the Middle East. US hawks have been muted, with China policy appearing to be directed primarily via the trade secretary, Scott Bessent.

The US hopes to establish alternative sources of rare earths. Deng Xiaoping urged China to “hide its light and bide its time” in foreign policy; now US officials joke of adopting his strategy. But others think that the US needs to move fast to tighten controls on exports of advanced technologies, and make serious progress in “de-risking” supply chains. They fear Mr Trump, who likes quick wins, is trading long-term national security for short‑term economic gain.

For China, its economic, technological and security progress are inextricably linked. It wants time to surpass the US on all scores. Last month Beijing ordered Meta to unwind its purchase of Manus, a Chinese-founded AI firm. It also introduced new measures to punish companies compliant in sanctions against Chinese firms.

Mr Xi called the Beijing meeting a “milestone”. That’s better understood as a marker on a long journey than a major achievement. China believes it is on the path to restored greatness, while Chen Yixin, minister for state security, wrote scathingly in December that US hegemony is “increasingly unsustainable … At home, its democracy is mutating, its economy decaying, and its society fracturing … abroad, its credibility is rapidly going bankrupt, its hegemony is crumbling, and its myth is collapsing.”