Breaking
DEZwei Tote bei missglücktem Überholmanöver auf L1165DEIran-Konflikt: USA und Iran einigen sich auf WaffenruheRUОдин человек погиб при атаке БПЛА в Саратовской областиCN台北市敦化北路驚現巨大天坑 瓦斯管線破裂傳濃烈瓦斯味DEPakistanisches Frachtflugzeug vor Karachi vermisstARربع النهائي: 8 منتخبات تتنافس على 4 مقاعد في نصف النهائيCN上海张江药谷:青年人才成为创新药研发主力军ARالدولار يرتفع لأعلى مستوى في أسبوع وسط تجدد التوترات مع إيران ورفع نيوزيلندا لأسعار الفائدةCN“开辟了实现中华民族伟大复兴的正确道路”——深入学习贯彻习近平总书记在庆祝中国共产党成立105周年大会上重要讲话系列述评之二RUТрансграничная канатная дорога между Благовещенском и Хэйхэ готова на 96%DEZwei Tote bei missglücktem Überholmanöver auf L1165DEIran-Konflikt: USA und Iran einigen sich auf WaffenruheRUОдин человек погиб при атаке БПЛА в Саратовской областиCN台北市敦化北路驚現巨大天坑 瓦斯管線破裂傳濃烈瓦斯味DEPakistanisches Frachtflugzeug vor Karachi vermisstARربع النهائي: 8 منتخبات تتنافس على 4 مقاعد في نصف النهائيCN上海张江药谷:青年人才成为创新药研发主力军ARالدولار يرتفع لأعلى مستوى في أسبوع وسط تجدد التوترات مع إيران ورفع نيوزيلندا لأسعار الفائدةCN“开辟了实现中华民族伟大复兴的正确道路”——深入学习贯彻习近平总书记在庆祝中国共产党成立105周年大会上重要讲话系列述评之二RUТрансграничная канатная дорога между Благовещенском и Хэйхэ готова на 96%
Newsgather
BackJD Vance Criticized for Linking Catholic Faith to Opposition to 'Low-Wage Foreigners'
JD Vance Criticized for Linking Catholic Faith to Opposition to 'Low-Wage Foreigners'
Developing
TOI World6d agoPolitics2 min readIndia

JD Vance Criticized for Linking Catholic Faith to Opposition to 'Low-Wage Foreigners'

Quick Look

  • US Vice President JD Vance faced backlash for stating his Catholic faith opposes "low-wage foreigners" entering the US, with critics highlighting his wife's Hindu faith and questioning his interpretation of Christian teachings.
  • Vance argued his faith supports policies prioritizing American workers' dignity.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

US Vice President JD Vance stated his Catholic faith informs his opposition to "low-wage foreigners" entering the US, arguing it supports the dignity of American workers. This sparked criticism, particularly given his wife's Hindu faith.

Font size

US vice president JD Vance has come under fire after saying his Catholic faith supports policies that oppose "low-wage foreigners" entering the United States. Soicial media pointed to the fact that his wife, second lady Usha Vance, is an Indian-American and a practising Hindu. Vance made the remarks during an appearance on Fox News' The Ingraham Angle while discussing his new memoir, Communion: Finding My Way Back to Faith, which focuses on his conversion to Catholicism in 2019.

Asked by host Laura Ingraham how his faith influences his decisions in public office, Vance said his religion encourages humility and shapes his approach to policymaking.

"My faith is constantly asking me to have humility about what's going on, so one of the things that I try do Laura, is constantly ask myself 'What've we learned,' 'Has what we learn, is it consistent with what I thought was going to happen or inconsistent with what I thought was going to happen,'" he said.

He added, "I really do think the Christian faith causes political leaders to be humbled because real humility is how is how you learn, is how you learn about other people, it's how you make better decisions over the course of time."

Vance then linked his faith to the Trump administration's economic agenda.

"The other thing I'd say, Laura, is my faith motivates me to remember that our economic policy doesn't exist for corporations, it doesn't exist for Wall Street, as much as we want everybody to be successful, it exists to support the dignity of human beings," he said.

The VP added: "We want every American to be able to raise a family, to be able to support themselves in comfort and in dignity, that's why we're trying to bring investment and manufacturing back to the US"

He continued, "That's why we don't like low-wage foreigners coming in and undercutting the wages of American workers. We want normal Americans to be able to live a dignified life. I think that's a very, very Christian concept."

The clip went viral, where many users accused Vance of misrepresenting Christian teachings. One person wrote, "What faith is that? Jesus literally said 'blessed are the poor.'" Another personn wrote, "What he's saying, is not the teachings of Jesus." Another user said, "Jesus Christ was a low wage foreigner."

One comment was more personal: "Like your Hindu wife Usha"?

Usha Vance is the first Hindu second lady of US. An Indian American and the daughter of Indian immigrants, she was raised in a Hindu household in San Diego and is a Yale Law School graduate. Earlier this year, during an interview with CBS News, Usha Vance said she had no plans to convert to Catholicism like his husband. JD Vance later said he hoped she might one day embrace Christianity but clarified that "she has no plans to convert" and that he respected her decision. Her faith has previously drawn criticism from some within the MAGA movement, where conservatives questioned having a non-Christian, Brown second lady. The debate also followed JD Vance's past remarks describing US as a Christian nation.

Open Questions

  • How does Vance reconcile his views with Jesus' teachings on the poor?
  • What is Vance's specific definition of 'low-wage foreigners'?
  • Will this controversy impact Vance's political standing?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by TOI World.

Related Stories

गुजरात: हाईकोर्ट की फटकार के बाद बेघर हुए नासिरनगर के लोगों को घर मिलने की उम्मीद
Developing·1h ago

गुजरात: हाईकोर्ट की फटकार के बाद बेघर हुए नासिरनगर के लोगों को घर मिलने की उम्मीद

गुजरात हाईकोर्ट ने सूरत म्युनिसिपल कॉर्पोरेशन को गैरकानूनी तरीके से तोड़े गए मकानों के पीड़ितों के लिए आवास की व्यवस्था करने का निर्देश दिया है। 30 मई को 100 से अधिक कच्चे मकानों को तोड़ा गया था, जिससे लोग बेघर हो गए थे।

BBC हिंदी
More on this topicJD Vance