Judge Rules Transgender Prisoner Policy Unlawful in Scotland

A judge has ruled that prison guidance which allows some transgender prisoners to be held in jails matching their gender identity, rather than their sex at birth, is unlawful.

Judge Lady Ross said sex segregation in prisons must be based on biological sex, based on a Supreme Court ruling on the definition of a woman in equality law in April last year.

Campaign group For Women Scotland challenged the Scottish government guidance through a judicial review, saying only those born biologically female should be held in the women's estate.

Lawyers for the government had argued this would breach transgender prisoners' human rights. The first minister said they will take time to consider the judgement.

Lady Ross said the guidance was "in conflict with the requirement that prison accommodation be provided separately for men and women" and constituted "a mis-statement of the law".

Currently the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) uses a system of individual risk assessments which aims to keep anyone who poses a danger to women out of the female estate.

However, it does allow for circumstances where trans women - born biologically male - could be housed alongside women if they are deemed not to pose an unacceptable risk to them.

However, the court said Article 8 does not mean there is automatically a right for a transgender prisoner to be housed in a prison designated for the opposite biological sex.

Lady Ross said the right was qualified and may be restricted where there is a legitimate justification, including maintaining sex-based segregation within the prison estate.

In a case involving a serious threat to life, such as a risk of suicide, Article 2 of the ECHR — which protects the right to life — might require consideration of whether accommodation in a prison for the opposite biological sex was necessary.

For Women Scotland brought the case following its successful appeal to the Supreme Court about the definition of a woman in the Equality Act.

Susan Smith, a co-director of the group, said it was "delighted" to have won a "comprehensive victory".

"We hope that, in future, the Scottish government will start to listen to us rather than the lobby groups who drafted these policies and have so egregiously misled MSPs and MPs," she said.

"We should never have needed to take this case and we hope this will be the last time that we are forced to go to law to defend the rights of women."

First Minister, John Swinney told BBC Scotland Lady Ross's judgement was complex and the government will take time to consider its implications.

He said: "We will consider all of these details because there are complex issues that are involved, but at this early stage I acknowledge the outcome of the judgement from Lady Ross and the government will consider its findings.

"We will assess the implications the judgement has on carrying out policy in relation to the handling of prisoners."