Breaking
BRAccident with three cars leaves one person injured and causes 10 kilometers of congestion on Castello Branco in São RoqueIT60 million euro IPO concluded on the Bank of Cairo, listed on the stock exchangeFRSocial movements: Laurent Nuñez wrote to the police to show them his “very great gratitude”UKReform council leader quits after staff comments leakedBRWeather forecast today for Porto Alegre (RS): sun and lots of clouds in the afternoon; At night the sky is still very cloudy, but it doesn't rainTRTraffic density in Istanbul in the evening!ARA new government commissioner calls for strengthening the fight against anti-Semitism in GermanyTRAnthony Taylor statement from İbrahim Hacıosmanoğlu: 'He is also a bit broken friend'PLRussian bombs fell on the school. Many deadCNMother, 72, on trial in France over 1980s torture killing of 4-year-old daughterBRAccident with three cars leaves one person injured and causes 10 kilometers of congestion on Castello Branco in São RoqueIT60 million euro IPO concluded on the Bank of Cairo, listed on the stock exchangeFRSocial movements: Laurent Nuñez wrote to the police to show them his “very great gratitude”UKReform council leader quits after staff comments leakedBRWeather forecast today for Porto Alegre (RS): sun and lots of clouds in the afternoon; At night the sky is still very cloudy, but it doesn't rainTRTraffic density in Istanbul in the evening!ARA new government commissioner calls for strengthening the fight against anti-Semitism in GermanyTRAnthony Taylor statement from İbrahim Hacıosmanoğlu: 'He is also a bit broken friend'PLRussian bombs fell on the school. Many deadCNMother, 72, on trial in France over 1980s torture killing of 4-year-old daughter
Back沈榮欽國際視野》媒體洩題是醜聞
沈榮欽國際視野》媒體洩題是醜聞
NEWS
自由时报yesterdayOpinion2 min readChinaView translation

沈榮欽國際視野》媒體洩題是醜聞

媒體事前洩題將辯論變為表演,沈榮欽批評此舉等同於對觀眾的詐欺。

Quick Look

台北市長辯論會發生媒體事前洩題事件,沈榮欽批評此舉嚴重損害辯論鑑別候選人能力的初衷,將辯論變為讀稿表演,並質疑媒體將錯誤慣例化的辯解,認為這是一場針對觀眾的詐欺。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

台北市長辯論會中,媒體被指控事前向候選人洩題,引發社會對媒體公信力與選舉公正性的質疑。

Font size

台北市長辯論會媒體事前洩題一事,不僅是錯誤之舉,更是一樁醜聞。

無論是否經過雙方同意,媒體在市長辯論中事先洩題都是錯誤的,因為市長辯論並非僅屬於競選雙方,而是所有市民了解候選人的重要管道,事前洩題將辯論變為表演,不僅錯誤,而且已經達到醜聞的程度。

媒體事前洩題就像學校考試洩題,會把能力較差者的成績提升到和能力較好的人一樣,變成記憶力競賽,使得學校測驗喪失鑑別的效果。

媒體事前洩題比學校洩題更糟,因為候選人連背稿都不用,可以光明正大地在鏡頭前念稿。這樣一來,不僅讓對市政理解能力較差的候選人,產生不公平的優勢,也抹除了市民觀看辯論了解候選人的目的,變為用讀稿能力的好壞來評鑑候選人,不僅沒有幫助民眾了解候選人的能力,還產生誤導的效果。這場事件從頭到尾被蒙在鼓裡的只有觀眾,是一場針對觀眾的詐欺。

荒唐的是,參與的媒體表示,因為參考上屆選舉辯論洩題,所以本屆選舉同樣洩題。那麼下屆選舉是否可以繼續參考本屆,形成洩題慣例?將錯誤變為常態,這種說詞實在荒謬。

而且其中還有些疑點並未釐清,媒體表示是經過雙方同意才事前洩題,但是沈伯洋陣營卻表示,並不清楚主辦單位為何會做出事前提供題目的決定,讓此事變得十分可疑,需要釐清真相。

最令人感嘆的是,當事的媒體居然絲毫不認為事前洩題傷害媒體的公信力,反而振振有詞地將醜聞視為理所當然,連媒體都自視公信力如糞土,又如何要民眾產生信任?

Open Questions

  • 媒體事前洩題的具體決策過程為何?
  • 沈伯洋陣營對洩題事件的確切立場與知情程度。

Related Topics

This article was originally published by 自由时报.

Related Stories

German media: Facing the powers of China and the United States, should middle powers unite for warmth?
Developing·

German media: Facing the powers of China and the United States, should middle powers unite for warmth?

German Chancellor Mertz recently visited Asia to deal with trade pressure and economic dependence between the United States and China. Media comments believe that Merz has become tougher on China and is trying to build an alliance of middle powers to safeguard the interests of Germany's export-oriented economy by strengthening communication with Asian allies.

德国之声
5 min read
Slow Review》Jiang Wanan’s wife said that the connections between people that led to Huida’s investment should have been a blinding event.
Opinion·

Slow Review》Jiang Wanan’s wife said that the connections between people that led to Huida’s investment should have been a blinding event.

Shi Fanggen, wife of Taipei Mayor Chiang Wanan, caused controversy by claiming that she contacted Huida CEO Huang Jen-Hsun to promote the Beishike headquarters through her husband's personal connections. Commentators pointed out that this statement ignored the deep foundation laid by the Ministry of Economic Affairs in early investment promotion, establishment of R&D centers and inter-ministerial tax system negotiations over the years.

自由时报
9 min read
Free Lectures》Length of holidays, real oppression: China’s labor dilemma under adjusted leave
Opinion·

Free Lectures》Length of holidays, real oppression: China’s labor dilemma under adjusted leave

Although the National Day holiday lasts for seven days, it has to be compensated by making up work on the weekends before and after it, causing office workers to express their dissatisfaction by reducing travel and consumption. The incident highlights labor difficulties such as low wages and overwork, as well as the phenomenon that people's demands for two days off are suppressed by the authorities.

自由时报
4 min read
"Free to Talk", can the old drama of tragedy and hatred save Jiang Wanan's election?
Developing·

"Free to Talk", can the old drama of tragedy and hatred save Jiang Wanan's election?

This article comments on the founding meeting of Jiang Wanan’s campaign headquarters, pointing out that he used the mobilization techniques of tragedy and hatred that have remained unchanged for 30 years to set the tone of the election campaign to defeat the evil devil, and called for the election to return to the expectation of a better life rather than being trapped in hatred.

自由时报
3 min read
Outside the Wall Digest: 33 people were expelled from the party, why can’t Xi Jinping be held accountable?
Developing·

Outside the Wall Digest: 33 people were expelled from the party, why can’t Xi Jinping be held accountable?

The Fifth Plenary Session of the 20th Central Committee of the Communist Party of China concluded and confirmed the expulsion of 33 senior officials from the party. Scholars commented that it strengthened Xi Jinping's centralization of power and governance crisis; reports on the same occasion analyzed the "Sichuanization" phenomenon of Chinese liberals and lighthouse doctrine.

德国之声
6 min read
More on this topic台北市長辯論