Constitutional law expert Anne Twomey argues the federal government lacks constitutional authority to fund sporting club upgrades, citing misuse of grant programs and noting no political incentive to end the practice, amid live coverage of federal politics including Labor's proposed tobacco trade laws and gas reservation policy.
AI-generated summary
The federal government has been funding community projects, including sporting club upgrades, through grant programs, raising constitutional questions about the appropriate use of Commonwealth funds.
Not only is the federal government facing questions about how it chose to fund certain community projects last election, but now the legality of these types of schemes are under question.
Constitutional law expert Anne Twomey says the Commonwealth shouldn't be using money to pay for sporting club upgrades.
"The framers of the Constitution did not write the Constitution so that the Commonwealth Parliament could go around spending money on facilities at golf clubs or resurfacing football ovals," she said.
"That is not a federal responsibility".
Other government grant programs have come under fire too and Professor Twomey reckons if they landed in court, they'd be unconstitutional.
But she can't see a challenge happening anytime soon.
"This has been going on for an awfully long time. All sides of government do it and abuse the system and none of them have an interest in actually stopping this conduct," she said.
Hello and welcome to our federal politics live blog. It's great to have you join us here for the final sitting day of the week this Thursday morning.
I'm Josh Boscaini joining you live from Parliament House in Canberra, here and ready to bring you all of today's federal politics news.
A constitutional law expert says it's not the responsibility of the federal government to hand out money to sporting clubs, after the ABC revealed the PM held an undeclared honorary membership to a club which received a Commonwealth grant.
Meanwhile, Labor is set to introduce laws to parliament today to crack down on the illegal tobacco trade and target organised crime, distributors and retailers selling illegal cigarettes.
And we expect the federal government will unveil its gas reservation policy today. Earlier this year, Labor proposed forcing gas giants to save 20 per cent of their volumes for the Australian market.
Without further ado, let's get right into the day!
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
Labor will introduce laws to parliament to crack down on the illegal tobacco trade
Very likely · Within hours
The federal government will unveil its gas reservation policy today
Very likely · Within hours
Western Australia's opposition has criticized the state government's $30 million 'State of Energy' campaign promoting the renewable energy transition as a waste of money, arguing funds should instead be used to upgrade facilities. Shadow energy minister Steve Thomas claims the 2029 coal phase-out timeline is unrealistic and that the campaign misleads the public, while the government defends the initiative as essential for public engagement and investment attraction, with metrics focused on awareness and confidence in the transition.
British police have opened a criminal investigation into Reform UK following a Channel 4 documentary alleging the party broke electoral law by arranging foreign funding for political polling. The Metropolitan Police confirmed the investigation expands an existing probe into donations, citing potential offences. Reform UK, led by Nigel Farage, denies wrongdoing, calls the allegations a hoax by climate activists, and states it will fully cooperate while declining further comment during the ongoing investigation.
The South Australian branch of the Headstone Project has raised concerns that federal funding for unmarked World War I veteran graves falls significantly short of pre-election 2022 promises, despite federal grants contributing $620 per grave.
Opposition frontbencher Andrew Hastie labels Pauline Hanson and Barnaby Joyce 'lying cowards' amid an escalating dispute over a One Nation video describing him as a 'traitor' for testifying in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation case.
The Tasmanian government's proposed 5% visitor tax on short-stay accommodation was defeated in the state's upper house after a 6-6 tie, with the president using his casting vote to reject it. Treasurer Eric Abetz accused Labor of hypocrisy, while critics argued the levy would not address housing affordability and lacked proper modelling. The tax was intended to fund stamp duty exemptions for first home buyers but was seen as ineffective by independents and the Greens, who supported it only as a revenue measure.
Gerard Maley, the Northern Territory's deputy chief minister, defended his failure to publicly disclose that his sister-in-law works for Beetaloo Energy, the firm involved in a proposed $40 billion data centre deal outside Darwin, stating he followed disclosure rules 'to a T' and informed the chief minister despite believing no conflict existed.