Breaking
ESLa IA no se frena en Bolsa: Anthropic se dispara un 33% en su debut en el NasdaqCRYPTO-ENAnthropic Stock Opens 33% Above IPO Price as AI Stocks RallyDERekord-Börsengang: Aktien von Anthropic legen bei Debüt um 34 Prozent zuDENiedersachsen: SPD-Justizministerin Kathrin Wahlmann tritt zurückFR+35 % à sa première cotation : Anthropic bat tous les records pour ses débuts à Wall StreetDEBörse: Schwere Vorwürfe: AMD-Aktie verliert nach Shortseller-Bericht deutlichUKAttempted murder arrest after councillor stabbedAR"لن نتهاون مع أي اعتداء".. بيان سعودي بعد هجوم الحوثيين على مركز الملك عبدالله الماليBRAções da Anthropic sobem 34% no primeiro pregãoESEl segundo borrador de la COP31 elimina la mención a los "combustibles fósiles"ESLa IA no se frena en Bolsa: Anthropic se dispara un 33% en su debut en el NasdaqCRYPTO-ENAnthropic Stock Opens 33% Above IPO Price as AI Stocks RallyDERekord-Börsengang: Aktien von Anthropic legen bei Debüt um 34 Prozent zuDENiedersachsen: SPD-Justizministerin Kathrin Wahlmann tritt zurückFR+35 % à sa première cotation : Anthropic bat tous les records pour ses débuts à Wall StreetDEBörse: Schwere Vorwürfe: AMD-Aktie verliert nach Shortseller-Bericht deutlichUKAttempted murder arrest after councillor stabbedAR"لن نتهاون مع أي اعتداء".. بيان سعودي بعد هجوم الحوثيين على مركز الملك عبدالله الماليBRAções da Anthropic sobem 34% no primeiro pregãoESEl segundo borrador de la COP31 elimina la mención a los "combustibles fósiles"
BackDoes Australia really have the world’s second most generous refugee scheme?
Does Australia really have the world’s second most generous refugee scheme?
Politics
Guardian AustraliayesterdayPolitics3 min readAustralia

Does Australia really have the world’s second most generous refugee scheme?

One Nation leader proposes 90% cut to humanitarian program, citing global rankings

Quick Look

  • One Nation leader Pauline Hanson proposed cutting Australia's annual refugee intake from 20,000 to 2,000, claiming Australia ranks second globally behind Canada.
  • Fact-checking reveals that while Australia ranks high for UNHCR resettlement, it ranks lower on broader asylum metrics.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

Australia currently accepts 20,000 refugees annually under its humanitarian program. The UNHCR processes refugee resettlement globally, which is distinct from border-based asylum claims.

Font size

Pauline Hanson has claimed Australia’s refugee program is so generous it ranks second in the world only just behind Canada.

The One Nation leader used the claim on Wednesday to justify proposing the program be slashed by 90% from 20,000 places a year to just 2,000 if the minor rightwing party were to lead government.

Australia would still remain above the OECD average for places per capita, she claimed.

So, is Australia really punching “well above its weight” on the global stage when it comes to accepting refugees? Well, not quite to the level Hanson would like us to think.

What Hanson said…

At a press conference in Parliament House on Wednesday, Hanson said Australia had taken its share of refugees but it was now time to rein it in.

“If you look at the … only other country is Canada, and we’re second highest [behind] Canada. Even the United States only takes in 12,000. They’ve got a population of 12 times our numbers, and yet you’ve got other countries don’t even take it in whatsoever. You’ve got New Zealand’s only on 280 [per million], so we punch way above our weight,” she said.

“Our humanitarian responsibility starts here in our own country first and foremost.”

The Queensland senator said reducing the number of places from 20,000 to 2,000 in conjunction with scrapping the permanent parent visa program would save the federal budget $140bn over a decade.

Relying on an internal One Nation analysis, based on Treasury modelling and adjusted for inflation, Hanson said the lifetime cost of a humanitarian entrant was $523,000.

Doing so would still keep Australia “above the OECD average for places per capita” or at least in line with it.

The whole picture

It’s true that Australia comes in second place for the most places per capita offered to refugees processed under the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

According to its latest figures, three countries – Canada, Australia and the United States – accounted for 84% of all refugee resettlements in 2025.

But the UNHCR is not the only way the world’s refugees are resettled.

A large number of global asylum claims are processed at borders but not in Australia because of its ocean borders.

And, according to those figures as shown in a government analysis of OECD data, Australia remains in the top 10 countries offering pathways for refugees but ranks below Canada, Germany, France and even New Zealand on a per capita basis.

Under Hanson’s proposal, Australia would drop to just a fraction of the US’s reduced refugee settlement program after it was controversially suspended by US president Donald Trump.

The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre said Australia’s long history of being among the top countries in the world to offer refugees a permanent home should be a source of national pride rather than a political football.

“This is about more than numbers. It is about who we are as a country. We have a choice to be mean or generous,” Jana Favero, the centre’s deputy chief executive, said.

“We all know a refugee and have a proud history over the years of welcoming people fleeing Vietnam, Sri Lanka, Ukraine, Iran, Afghanistan and former Yugoslavia. This is the Australia we love and celebrate and any other version must be rejected.”

Open Questions

  • Will the proposed 90% cut be included in official party policy platforms?
  • How would the proposed visa changes impact long-term economic projections?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by Guardian Australia.

Related Stories

Government urged to drop references to 'religion' in terrorism definition
Developing·

Government urged to drop references to 'religion' in terrorism definition

Australia's independent national security legislation monitor Jake Blight recommends removing religion from the terrorism definition and broadening ideology to capture religious motives, citing lower conviction rates for racist and nationalist cases compared to ISIS-inspired cases. The federal government and security agencies have expressed reluctance, while some Muslim groups support the change.

ABC Top Stories
4 min read
More on this topicpauline hanson