I do not have confidence UK is safe from Russian threats, says Swinney
Quick Look
- First Minister John Swinney said he lacks confidence in the UK's ability to defend against potential Russian threats, citing insufficient military presence in Scottish coastal waters.
- He made the remarks ahead of the SNP's annual conference, where he also denied that Scottish independence would weaken national security and welcomed Labour leader Andy Burnham's visit to discuss devolution and trade.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
The UK government oversees national defence, including the nuclear submarine base at Faslane in Scotland. The SNP opposes nuclear weapons but supports an independent Scotland joining NATO. MI5 has identified Russia as the top aggressor, raising concerns about coastal security.
First Minister John Swinney says he does not have confidence the UK is safe from potential Russian threats.
The SNP leader said the UK government, which is in charge of Britain's defences, did not have a sufficient "presence" in vulnerable areas off Scotland's coast.
He said he was "very worried" by security fears highlighted this week by the head of MI5, Sir Ken McCallum, who named Russia as "aggressor number one".
Speaking to BBC Scotland News ahead of the SNP's annual conference, Swinney also denied that independence would weaken Scotland's security.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said his government is committed to investing in defence, including nuclear deterrence, while not seeking to escalate tensions with Russia.
Asked about the MI5 chief's comments, the first minister said he was "very worried" about a "lack of coastal and offshore protection".
He identified waters north of Shetland as an area of significant Russian activity.
"I don't think we've got nearly the presence in those areas that we require today," he told BBC Scotland News.
"There's an obligation on the United Kingdom government to make sure that the country is safe. And I don't think the defence posture of the United Kingdom enables me to have that confidence."
Scotland is home to the UK's nuclear submarine fleet at Faslane, west of Glasgow. The SNP wants those weapons to be removed, but is in favour of an independent Scotland joining Nato.
Swinney insisted that independence would not hamper Scotland's security, but rather give the country "more choices".
The SNP leader said he had "always been a believer in defence co-operation between Scotland and other countries", citing Canada joining the EU's SAFE defence programme, external.
Delivering a speech at the UN General Assembly, external last month, Burnham said his government would invest in defence and build up the UK's "hard power and deterrence".
He added: "But we will not play Russia's game of trading escalatory rhetoric. Unlike Russia, we do not seek confrontation."
SNP members are gathering in Aberdeen for the party's annual conference, which starts on Thursday and ends with Swinney's keynote speech on Saturday afternoon.
Burnham has also selected this weekend to visit Scotland. He is expected to travel to the central belt to discuss plans to devolve power to local communities.
Swinney, who has invited the Labour leader to the SNP conference, said he had "not yet" accepted the offer.
The first minister welcomed Burnham's recent announcement that he wanted to secure better trade terms with the EU for producers of salmon, shellfish, and seed potatoes.
The prime minister also wants to discuss even closer ties with the bloc and has not ruled out a future referendum on rejoining.
Swinney told the BBC: "I think it's an interesting precedent that if we can reopen an issue that's been decided by a referendum, then we can also reopen Scottish independence."
Swinney was also challenged on the preparedness of the NHS for winter pressures after an emergency doctor warned of "unsafe levels of care" and a "toxic normalisation" of corridor care.
Dr Fiona Hunter, vice-chair of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine in Scotland, told BBC Scotland News that she was "completely terrified" of the situation.
The first minister said he could "hear, understand and appreciate" these concerns and accepted that there were "significant challenges" in the system.
However, he said hospital flow plans were designed to reduce pressures and the Scottish government intended to end corridor care "at the earliest possible opportunity".
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The UK government will announce increased naval patrols or surveillance in waters north of Shetland.
Likely · Within weeks
SNP members will debate Scottish independence strategy at the annual conference in Aberdeen.
Very likely · Within days
Open Questions
- What specific measures will the UK government take to increase presence in Scottish coastal waters?
- Will the SNP conference lead to a renewed push for Scottish independence?
- How will NHS Scotland address corridor care and winter pressures?







