Birthing services at Carnarvon Hospital in Western Australia have been suspended since February 2022 due to midwife and obstetrician shortages, forcing parents to travel over 1,000km to give birth, incurring significant costs and emotional strain despite government promises to cover expenses and restore services.
AI-generated summary
Birthing services at Carnarvon Hospital were suspended in February 2022 due to a shortage of midwives and obstetricians, leaving expectant parents in the Gascoyne region without local access to maternity care.
New parents say their mental and physical health are at risk after almost five years without birthing services at a key country hospital.
Birthing services were suspended at Carnarvon Hospital, about 900 kilometres north of Perth, in February 2022 due to a shortage of midwives and obstetricians.
As a result, Gascoyne parents have been forced to take extra leave from work, some travelling more than 1,000km to give birth.
Carnarvon residents Tarlia Hill and Michael Wilkins are preparing to make that same journey to have their first child in Geraldton.
"I'm a bit scared of being in a car for that long that close to having my baby," Ms Hill said.
Despite a difficult pregnancy, Ms Hill said the lack of services in Carnarvon had affected her the most.
One of her biggest battles was for her mother to be allowed to stay at the accommodation to support her through her first pregnancy.
"You're supposed to be excited and I haven't been excited at all," she said.
"I've got a really good support system behind me, but I couldn't imagine what some of the other mums could be going through if they don't have the same support."
Having watched his sister wait months for reimbursement under WA's Patient Assisted Travel Scheme (PATS), Mr Wilkins said he and his partner could not afford it.
He said the birth was costing them about $10,000, and paying several thousand dollars more for accommodation up-front was not possible.
The couple have now had their accommodation paid in full.
But if their baby is late, it will be their responsibility to find and pay for more accommodation.
"I've got no leave really behind me, and due to my position at work, I can't access parental leave or anything to support us while we're down there," Mr Wilkins said.
No services for new mothers
Jessica Halpin has already gone through the experience of travelling to have her baby, and was told she needed to go to Perth four weeks before her due date.
She said she was "luckily" provided accommodation at the Ronald McDonald House (RMH).
With her family in the UK, she said she would have been more than $10,000 out of pocket without the space at RMH.
"Before I gave birth, it was fine," Ms Halpin said.
"After giving birth, with all your hormones changing and crashing, that was hard because I was quite anxious."
Ms Halpin said explaining her pregnancy to a different midwife at every appointment also took a toll.
"Everyone reassured me, but to have someone who had known you throughout your pregnancy would have felt a lot better," she said.
When the couple returned to Carnarvon, Ms Halpin had little support.
Her partner had run out of parental leave and had to return to work, and she had to go through a difficult breastfeeding process without a lactation consultant in town.
"Having that in-person contact is just a lot better. It feels more personal and you can have a proper conversation without worrying if the wi-fi is dropping out."
A WA Country Health Service (WACHS) spokesperson said in a statement it had supported 359 women from the region to give birth at a location of their choice since the suspension.
The spokesperson said WACHS was committed to re-establishing birthing services, and was still actively recruiting to fill workforce gaps.
Promises not kept
Premier Roger Cook told parliament in 2024 that mothers travelling from Carnarvon to give birth would not need to access the PATS scheme and the government would fully cover costs.
Mid-West MP Shane Love said this was at odds with what families in his electorate were telling him.
"Families are having to shell out thousands of dollars up front and wait months before they can claim that money back," Mr Love said.
"It's simply not good enough and the government needs to lift its game.
"I don't think they are trying very hard. If they were, they would have someone there. 1,700 days is a long time to run a recruitment process."
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
Birthing services will be partially restored at Carnarvon Hospital within the next 6 months as recruitment efforts continue
Possible · Within months
More families will continue to incur significant out-of-pocket expenses for travel and accommodation until full cost coverage is implemented
Likely · Within months
Donna Rullo, diagnosed with HER2-positive breast cancer in 2001, joined the HERA trial for trastuzumab after driving five hours to hear oncologist Richard Bell speak. Her participation contributed to the drug's PBS listing in 2006, making it accessible to thousands of Australian women and improving long-term survival rates.
Eli Lilly launched LillyDirect in Australia to deliver Mounjaro directly to patients via online pharmacists, drawing criticism from doctors and pharmacists who argue it compromises patient safety by reducing clinical oversight and continuity of care, despite claims of improved affordability and convenience.
A non-verbal man with pneumonia waited nine hours in an ambulance outside Adelaide's Lyell McEwin Hospital amid severe emergency department overcrowding, with the doctors' union reporting demand at double capacity.
The father of Jennifer Matters, who died by suicide in 2021 after battling anorexia nervosa, urges South Australia to adopt coroner recommendations for improved eating disorder services.
The ACT government will roll out the federal Thriving Kids program from October 1, ahead of its national launch in January 2028, to support children with developmental delays. Minister Suzanne Orr confirmed children under nine currently on the NDIS will not lose support, despite concerns the program may divert some from the scheme. The initiative offers a phone line for parental guidance regardless of diagnosis.
Former ABC Classic presenter Margaret Throsby, 84, suffered a hip fracture and head injuries after being struck by an e-bike ridden by two teenage boys on a shared path in the Illawarra, south of Sydney. Her family is calling for restrictions on teenagers' use of certain e-bikes, citing safety concerns and the normalization of heavy, fast bikes resembling motorbikes being ridden by unlicensed minors. Transport for NSW acknowledged the incident as concerning and noted existing regulations, while safety advocates call for mandatory education and ID tags for young riders.