BackUkrainians dying because US restricting intelligence sharing, Zelensky adviser tells BBC
Ukrainians dying because US restricting intelligence sharing, Zelensky adviser tells BBC
Developing
BBC World1 hour agoWorld2 min readUnited Kingdom

Ukrainians dying because US restricting intelligence sharing, Zelensky adviser tells BBC

Quick Look

A key adviser to President Zelensky told the BBC that Ukrainians have died because Kyiv is not receiving reliable US warnings of incoming Russian ballistic missile strikes, citing inconsistent intelligence sharing and ongoing Starlink restrictions that hinder drone operations and military communications, despite White House denials of any changes to intelligence sharing.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

Ukraine has relied on US intelligence for early warnings of Russian ballistic missile and drone attacks, and uses Starlink and its military variant Starshield for battlefield communications and drone operations. Tensions arose after a dispute over US policy on Russian oil imports, leading to reported pauses in intelligence sharing and network restrictions.

Font size

Ukrainians have died because Kyiv is still not receiving reliable US warnings of incoming Russian attacks, according to a key adviser to President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Serhii "Flash" Beskrestnov told the BBC that lives had been lost because there had not been time to warn citizens about ballistic missile strikes, saying: "It's dangerous... I think it's really very bad... People [have] already died."

The adviser also said restrictions to Ukraine's use of the Starlink internet network were ongoing.

The White House said there had been no changes to intelligence sharing with Ukraine.

Ukraine first reported an interruption to US intelligence sharing last week, as a row with the Trump administrations over its controversial deal to import Russian oil sent relations to new lows.

Despite the denials from Washington, many in Kyiv suspect the issues are not a coincidence.

On Monday morning, Zelensky wrote on social media: "Overnight two ballistic missile attacks were reported on the capital, one without warning, the second with only minimal time to take shelter."

Hours earlier, an interview the president did with NBC was published, in which he said intelligence sharing had been restored after a three-day pause.

"We are very thankful for this," he said. "Only [the] United States has this unique intelligence to tell our side when Russia uses ballistic missiles."

But Beskrestnov told the BBC that American intelligence continued to be incomplete and inconsistent, and that the US had failed to provide a clear explanation for the issue.

"This looks very strange," he said. "Sometimes we receive this information before the attack, another time we [do] not."

He continued: "And for example, last night we received it, but... one minute before the attack."

However, he said other collaboration with US continues, adding: "Intelligence data keeps flowing, and the issue is solely with the air raid alert component."

Beskrestnov also said the US had given no clarity about who was responsible for the ongoing restrictions to the Starlink internet network and its military service Starshield, which Kyiv uses to provide connectivity for drones, helicopters and military communications.

Last week, Starshield restricted the speed at which mobile units could move while staying connected to the network to 100mph (160km/h).

This has limited Ukraine's ability to shoot down incoming drones or to launch mid-range drone attacks into Russian-occupied areas.

Starlink owner Elon Musk said last week that the US government ultimately controls access to Starshield, which was designed for the Pentagon, suggesting it may therefore be behind the restrictions. Trump has denied involvement.

Beskrestnov said he thought both issues occurring at the same time was "probably" a deliberate move to put pressure on Ukraine.

He told BBC News: "It's probably the United States trying to say [to] us, 'let's have the conversation, negotiation with Russia, you should find the compromise'."

Beskrestnov also said Ukraine had its own radar data to provide some limited warning of incoming attacks, but was urgently looking into using alternative communication systems.

He added: "Now we understand that something begins to happen with Starlink, and we're not sure what will be the next step.

"We understand that we should be prepared for some problems in future. And now we're thinking about an alternative for Starlink, not only for air defence, for communication between our forces, between our staff, for civilians also, because we don't know what we should expect in future regarding Starlink."

Earlier on Monday, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said there had not been a "pause" to intelligence sharing.

"I don't know where [Zelensky is] getting these things or why he's saying these things to the press," he told reporters on Monday.

Rubio said he could not comment on the incident, adding: "I know a few nights ago there was a software problem involving their early warning system."

The BBC has contacted Starlink for a response.

A White House official said there were no changes to intelligence sharing operations between the US and Ukraine.

The official spoke on background to discuss intelligence matters. Trump is focused on ending the war, the official said, and added that the US has provided more aid to Ukraine than any other country.

Russian attacks continued late on Monday, with Ukrainian officials saying at least six people were killed - including a toddler in her pram and an 11-year-old girl - in a drone strike near a park café in the north-eastern Kharkiv region.

Zelensky described the attack in which another 14 people were injured as "absolute atrocity".

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • Ukraine will seek and implement alternative communication and early warning systems to reduce dependence on Starlink and US intelligence

    Likely · Within months

  • The US will face continued pressure to restore full intelligence sharing and Starlink functionality amid public and diplomatic scrutiny

    Likely · Within weeks

Open Questions

  • Who is responsible for the restrictions on Starlink and Starshield services in Ukraine?
  • What specific technical or political issues are causing the inconsistency in US intelligence sharing?
  • Will Ukraine accelerate development of alternative early warning and communication systems?
  • How will the degradation in US support affect Ukraine's ability to defend against future Russian attacks?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by BBC World.

Related Stories

Trump says suspension of Russia sanctions is to keep peace negotiations going
Developing·

Trump says suspension of Russia sanctions is to keep peace negotiations going

US President Donald Trump suspended several Russian sanctions to prevent Moscow from walking away from Ukraine peace negotiations, citing his goal of achieving peace in the Russia-Ukraine war. The move came as tensions with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky escalated, with Zelensky warning that siding with Putin would be a historic mistake. Russian envoy Kirill Dmitriev praised the decision as historic, while Trump accused Zelensky of not wanting to end the war and claimed he could have secured a better deal earlier. Relations between Washington and Kyiv have deteriorated following a controversial US deal to import Russian diesel and perceived reductions in military support to Ukraine.

BBC World
1 min read
More on this topicukraine