Victoria's Big Build inquiry hears CFMEU threatened to 'smash' subcontractor
Contractor John Holland wary of union influence on Gap Road level crossing removal project
Quick Look
Victoria's Big Build royal commission heard that contractor John Holland was wary of the CFMEU's unprecedented access to government ministers and alleged threats against subcontractors, including a threat to 'smash' a subcontractor, during a work stoppage at the Gap Road level crossing removal project in Sunbury in June 2022 that caused an estimated $6 million cost blowout.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
Victoria's Big Build royal commission is exploring allegations related to the conduct of the CFMEU on construction sites, including a work stoppage at the Gap Road level crossing removal project in Sunbury in June 2022. The commission has received private hearings and requests for more than 110,000 documents.
Victoria's Big Build royal commission has heard a major contractor was wary of the "unprecedented access" the CFMEU had to government ministers, as well as alleged threats against subcontractors.
A level crossing removal project at Sunbury, in Melbourne's outer north, was the focus of the first day of a two-week block of public hearings.
The royal commission is exploring a number of themes, including allegations related to the conduct of the CFMEU (Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union) on sites.
Counsel assisting the commission Chris Young KC noted that all of the themes being canvassed were allegations at this stage, some of which had been denied.
Contractor cautious of CFMEU's sway
Events related to a work stoppage at the Gap Road project in June 2022 were the focus of Monday's hearing.
Work ceased on June 6 and resumed on June 7 after control of the site was transferred to the CFMEU.
The commission heard that project costs blew out by an estimated $6 million.
Passages from several internal memos from site contractor John Holland were read out during today's hearing, including allegations about the CFMEU's relationship with the Victorian government.
"It is worth noting the significance of the CFMEU's relationship with the Andrews government in Victoria and the impact this is having and will have in the future in respect to client relationships," a memo dated to 2017 said.
"The union movement played a critical role in the election of the government, both organisationally and financially. The premier is factionally aligned with the Socialist Left and the CFMEU is the key industrial organisation in that faction.
"We also understand the CFMEU have unprecedented access to ministers and other key Victorian government stakeholders.
The commission heard that John Holland was increasingly cautious in its interactions with the CFMEU, with documents describing an escalating campaign by the union on the Gap Road site leading up to the June 2022 stop-work.
CFMEU threatened to 'smash' subcontractor, commission hears
Allegations of threats of violence against subcontractors were also aired during today's hearing.
One instance was captured in notes from an internal contractor meeting about conduct on site ahead of the June 2022 stop-work.
The commission heard that police and WorkSafe Victoria were notified, but that Victoria Police took no action as it was regarded as an occupational health and safety issue.
Wagstaff Piling subsequently told firms they would not be working, citing pressure from the union.
The royal commission has already received a raft of information, including private hearings and requests for more than 110,000 documents.
The hearings come as Victorians prepare to head to the polls for the November 28 state election.
Premier Ben Carroll today denied any knowledge of the CFMEU's access to senior government officials and ministers.
"What today's hearings show is that I am a premier that will make the tough decisions," Mr Carroll said.
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The royal commission will continue to hear evidence about CFMEU conduct on Big Build sites over the two-week hearing block.
Very likely · Within weeks
Further allegations about CFMEU access to ministers will be examined during the hearings.
Likely · Within weeks
Open Questions
- What specific actions will the royal commission take regarding the alleged threats against subcontractors?
- Will Victoria Police or WorkSafe Victoria pursue any further action on the reported incidents?
- What evidence supports the claim of CFMEU's unprecedented access to ministers?
