Breaking
FRA mobile gendarme victim of a Molotov cocktail thrown in Paris at the end of the demonstration on October 31TRBREAKING WORLD NEWS: US Secretary of State Rubio pointed out the critical area! 'We are examining Türkiye's suggestions'CNKaohsiung Green Building’s momentum chairs flooded the front of the Blue Camp’s presidential election. Li Yajing criticized the arrogance of the ruling partyCN[WEB][Real-time] Huang Shijie, Xiang Bohan and Yangmei jointly competed for the general election. Wu Siyao awarded the battle flag and ocean current flag, and Liang Wenjie presented the "Sharp Political Questioning" mug.BRMan enters cafeteria and shoots employee, in DFTRWhy did Erman Toroğlu resign? Why did Erman Toroğlu leave Sözcü?CNShen Boyang's live broadcast of car sweeping exceeded 120,000 people! Nie Yongzhen is here too. Daan Forest Park is packed with people.TRBreaking news...Armed attack near the stadium after the match in the USA! There are casualties and injuriesBRVIDEO: Fire destroys apartment in Bela Vista and takes hundreds of residents to the streets in the early hours of the morning; there were no injuriesBRFour young people die after car rolls over at AMG-1205, in FerrosFRA mobile gendarme victim of a Molotov cocktail thrown in Paris at the end of the demonstration on October 31TRBREAKING WORLD NEWS: US Secretary of State Rubio pointed out the critical area! 'We are examining Türkiye's suggestions'CNKaohsiung Green Building’s momentum chairs flooded the front of the Blue Camp’s presidential election. Li Yajing criticized the arrogance of the ruling partyCN[WEB][Real-time] Huang Shijie, Xiang Bohan and Yangmei jointly competed for the general election. Wu Siyao awarded the battle flag and ocean current flag, and Liang Wenjie presented the "Sharp Political Questioning" mug.BRMan enters cafeteria and shoots employee, in DFTRWhy did Erman Toroğlu resign? Why did Erman Toroğlu leave Sözcü?CNShen Boyang's live broadcast of car sweeping exceeded 120,000 people! Nie Yongzhen is here too. Daan Forest Park is packed with people.TRBreaking news...Armed attack near the stadium after the match in the USA! There are casualties and injuriesBRVIDEO: Fire destroys apartment in Bela Vista and takes hundreds of residents to the streets in the early hours of the morning; there were no injuriesBRFour young people die after car rolls over at AMG-1205, in Ferros
Back網怒蓋近千樓留言罵翻 盤點蔣萬安辯論的「十大謊言」!
網怒蓋近千樓留言罵翻  盤點蔣萬安辯論的「十大謊言」!
Developing
自由时报1 hour agoPolitics7 min readChinaView translation

網怒蓋近千樓留言罵翻 盤點蔣萬安辯論的「十大謊言」!

蔣萬安在辯論會上的發言遭網友與各界人士逐項打臉,從寶林茶室案、剴剴案到政績攬功引發熱烈討論。

Quick Look

台北市長電視辯論落幕,現任市長蔣萬安的發言遭網友與各界人士逐項打臉。網上列舉其涵蓋寶林茶室案、剴剴案、大巨蛋及輝達落腳等十大謊言與攬功爭議,引發近千樓留言與數萬人按讚。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

台北市長選戰電視辯論於10月31日舉行,現任市長蔣萬安與民進黨候選人沈伯洋展開交鋒。

Font size

備受各界關注的台北市長選戰電視辯論已於昨天(10/31)落幕,現任市長蔣萬安在辯論台上頻給民進黨候選人沈伯洋貼標籤、潑髒水,態度咄咄逼人,讓藍白選民看了直呼過癮,傾巢而出在網上狂刷「蔣市長完勝」,羅智強、徐巧芯等蔣競辦幹部也出來大肆嘲諷。可進一步檢視蔣萬安昨日的發言,許多網友都痛批幾乎通篇謊言,還有人特別邀集鄉民統計蔣萬安在台上說了多少謊,結果蓋了近千樓留言、數萬人按讚!

有網友昨晚在Threads上邀集大家盤點蔣萬安在與沈伯洋的辯論會上脫口說出的謊言,貼文曝光隨即引發熱烈迴響,以下整理最多網友提到的幾個「瞞天大謊」:

一、讓寶林茶室跑不了?

蔣萬安回答有關2024年3月份爆發造成6死悲劇的「寶林茶室集體食物中毒案」的問題時,聲稱事發第一時間,多虧市府同仁,讓後續檢方起訴掌握非常重要的證據,「讓寶林跑不了,讓受害家屬都能獲得賠償」。

可實情是台北市府未在第一時間實施假扣押,等到要追討罰鍰與進行求償時,才發現負責人名下的公司與個人資產早已全數移轉清空,目前在台灣基本上沒有任何可供執行的實質財產,包括對其開出累積總金額350萬元的行政罰鍰,至今一毛未繳納,受害者家屬求助無門。

二、處理兒虐事件都會面對面跟家長溝通?

沈伯洋談及包括「夏莉絲幼兒園案」在內等兒虐事件時,蔣萬安聲稱他都親自跟受虐孩童家長「面對面溝通」、「聆聽心聲並接下陳情書」,還端出自己是「三寶爸」的身分,強調看到孩子遭遇不當對待,一定負起責任。

其發言曝光才過沒多久,就有夏莉絲幼兒園案受害兒童家長在社群發文打臉,蔣萬安口中的「面對面溝通」,其實是家長長期求助無門、最後走投無路才親自前往市議會門口「堵人」才見到市長並遞交陳情書,並非市府主動安排。而且就算見到面,蔣萬安也沒有討論具體問題或做出承諾,怒斥市長將自己被堵到的過程美化成「主動傾聽」,令人感到憤怒。

三、重大食安會議親自召開?

沈伯洋在辯論會上針對重大食安事件與會議缺席率展開交鋒,蔣萬安聲稱其市府團隊在重大事件上絕對不逃避,他也一定都親自召開專案會議來指揮、掌握進度。

可根據台北市議會質詢與相關會議紀錄,蔣萬安擔任台北市食品安全委員會召集人,任內召開的食安會議缺席率高達73%(15次會議中缺席11次),且包含因寶林茶室、王品集團等重大食物中毒案召開的臨時會議,他也未親自出席。

四、剴剴案親自召開4次專案會議好棒棒?

沈伯洋也質疑蔣萬安在托育制度管理委員會未出席、兒少福利促進會等會議出席率僅7%。蔣萬安卻說市府採「分層負責」原則,這類例行會議多由副市長或主責局處主持。每當遇到不當對待事件,他都是「即刻召集各局處」並「親自主持專案會議」列管追蹤;他還特別舉曾震驚全國的「剴剴案」為例,稱自己針對該案親自主持4次專案會議。

一看蔣萬安還敢提剴剴案,鄉民群起砲轟,直指剴剴案發生在2023年12月,台北市社會局當月就已接獲通報並知情,蔣市府卻拖到2024年3月檢方起訴、媒體大肆曝光並引發全國民憤後,才開始動起來處理。外界質疑,如果真的有「即刻應變並召開4次會議」,為何中間有長達3個月的空窗期毫無作為,甚至被質疑第一時間企圖「蓋牌」。

不僅如此,剴剴案爆發初期,台北市議會曾原定召開臨時會,要求蔣萬安針對虐童案進行專案報告。但國民黨籍市議員集體缺席惡意杯葛,導致該次臨時會因人數不足而流會,外界怒轟蔣萬安在辯論台上講得自己有多積極處理這類重大兒虐案,回到事發當下明明就是透過同黨議員「技術性護航」,規避前往議會接受監督。

五、台北拿下李光耀城市獎?

蔣萬安在政見申論時提到台北市獲得了新加坡「李光耀世界城市獎」(Lee Kuan Yew World City Prize)。

可根據李光耀世界城市獎官方資料,2026年的首獎(得獎者)實際上是英國倫敦,台北市獲得的是「特別獎」(Special Mention),與比利時安特衛普、匈牙利布達佩斯、中國廣州與天津等城市並列。蔣萬安說法與事實有落差,涉嫌誇大或隱匿評選細節。

六、台南跟進台北實施生生喝鮮奶、免費營養午餐?

蔣萬安宣傳推動生生喝鮮奶、免費營養午餐政策時,對沈伯洋說「連你同黨的黃偉哲市長也都願意跟進,這是一個正確的方向」。

被點名的台南市長黃偉哲馬上跳出來打臉,台南早在2020年就推動學童乳品政策,台北則是2025年4月才上路。他也直言,台北並非全國第一個實施免費營養午餐的城市,早前包括金門、連江、新竹、苗栗、南投、宜蘭等縣市早就在實施,蔣萬安說台南跟進台北根本是在墊高自己。

七、學童營養午餐發生食安事件,蔣市府即刻對業者停業解約?

蔣市府8/31草率推行免費營養午餐,才過不到一週就發生台北市立成淵高中國中部午餐肉品有酸臭狀況,導致多達87名學童出現腹瀉等身體不適症狀。蔣萬安在辯論台上將這87名學子統稱為「1個個案」,市府第一時間就對提供「該個案」營養午餐的業者停業解約、啟動備援機制,並給予學生家長關懷與法律支援。

可輿論和相關監督團體打臉,直指該團膳業者:部分輿論與監督團體指出,該團膳廠商事實上並未全面終止對所有學校的服務,仍繼續供餐給其他6間高中,且裁罰金額才18萬元,外界紛紛質疑蔣市府的處置力道。

八、大巨蛋真的是蔣萬安的政績?

蔣萬安一直以來都將台北大巨蛋落成列為其重要施政成績,10/31的辯論會上也宣傳此事。

不過大巨蛋是在2012年4月17日動工興建,也就是從郝龍斌在任時間就開始;若要從評估興建方案開始算起,就得從1991年黃大洲擔任市長時算起,到2023年完工啟用,前後跨越了32年,經歷了6位台北市長。而且大巨蛋在2022年底,也就是前市長柯文哲卸任前就已大致完工並與遠雄完成議約,蔣萬安根本是收割前人成果。

九、輝達落腳台北是蔣萬安功勞?

輝達在台設立新總部,選址在北士科,近期也被蔣萬安時常掛在嘴邊宣傳,當作個人主要政績,接受專訪時還說是他「透過工程師友人牽線聯繫輝達執行長黃仁勳」,說得好像有他居中斡旋才能實現。昨天的辯論會上,蔣萬安自然也有宣傳這項他口中的「政績」。

事實上,經濟部早在2021年便已通過輝達申請的「人工智慧創新研發中心計畫」,確立其在台設立AI研發中心,外界批評蔣萬安是「往自己臉上貼金」、「攬功」。輝達選定台北建置總部,是中央與地方、跨部會、民間企業長期布局以及多方協調的結果,絕非單一市長的功勞。

十、Alex能爬台北101、12強能奪冠也靠蔣萬安?

除了「生生喝鮮奶、輝達落腳台北、大巨蛋完工啟用」等已經被大家背到滾瓜爛熟的「政績」,蔣萬安在辯論會申論階段還談及「台北精神」,提到美國極限攀岩好手霍諾德(Alex Honnold)徒手攀登101、台灣英雄從台北出發勇奪世界棒球12強賽冠軍,挨批「強蹭」、企圖「包裝成個人政績」。

實情是,霍諾德挑戰101是台北101董事長賈永婕頂住巨大的社會輿論與內部壓力拍板同意的,一度還被藍營的人批評。至於12強奪冠,許多棒球迷痛批國家隊選手血汗拚搏的冠軍榮耀「跟台北市長有什麼關係?」中職會長蔡其昌今天(11/1)也表示12強冠軍是全體教練、球員與後勤團隊努力的成果,「這不是任何人的政績,我也不會亂消費」。

網友當然還列出了更多謊言,整篇貼文蓋了近千樓留言,「其他的他喜歡誇大說都沒關係,寶林茶室、剴剴案他敢拿出來說欸,這都有資料能夠查到的,聽到整個超火大」、「東區90%店面招商成功?這個我剛聽到的時候就覺得說謊了吧」、「斯文里都更案是柯文哲任內完成的,跟蔣沒半毛關係」、「金華國中明明沒有檢體,哪裡有檢驗沒問題」、「真的是滿嘴謊話,別人所做的事蹟都變成他的政績,他真的敢說我都不敢聽,臉皮比我家牆壁還厚」、「還有繼續造謠沈伯洋挺毒、要在社區發毒品」、「他們很瞭解自己的選民不會去查證」。

Open Questions

  • 蔣競選團隊後續是否會針對網路指控做出具體回應?
  • 市府針對各項爭議政策將如何調整?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by 自由时报.

Related Stories

Kaohsiung Green Building’s momentum chairs flooded the front of the Blue Camp’s presidential election. Li Yajing criticized the arrogance of the ruling party
BREAKING·

Kaohsiung Green Building’s momentum chairs flooded the front of the Blue Camp’s presidential election. Li Yajing criticized the arrogance of the ruling party

Democratic Progressive Party Kaohsiung mayoral candidate Lai Ruilong and Assemblymember Zhang Hanzhong held the inaugural meeting of the presidential election in Fengshan. Because the seats were placed in front of the KMT candidates Ke Zhien and Li Yajing's presidential election, Li Yajing criticized the DPP for being arrogant and arrogant. The police immediately deployed police to build a human wall to avoid conflicts.

自由时报
2 min read
[WEB][Real-time] Huang Shijie, Xiang Bohan and Yangmei jointly competed for the general election. Wu Siyao awarded the battle flag and ocean current flag, and Liang Wenjie presented the "Sharp Political Questioning" mug.
BREAKING·

[WEB][Real-time] Huang Shijie, Xiang Bohan and Yangmei jointly competed for the general election. Wu Siyao awarded the battle flag and ocean current flag, and Liang Wenjie presented the "Sharp Political Questioning" mug.

The Democratic Progressive Party's Taoyuan mayoral candidate Huang Shijie and Yangmei District City Council candidate Xiang Bohan established a joint campaign headquarters over the weekend, with about 1,500 people attending. Many important figures in the party were present to support and used the flag-giving ceremony to symbolize the spirit of inheritance and professional service from generation to generation. Xiang Bohan emphasized that he would respond to the entrustment of the villagers with rational and professional governance.

自由时报
2 min read
Shen Boyang's live broadcast of car sweeping exceeded 120,000 people! Nie Yongzhen is here too. Daan Forest Park is packed with people.
BREAKING·

Shen Boyang's live broadcast of car sweeping exceeded 120,000 people! Nie Yongzhen is here too. Daan Forest Park is packed with people.

Taipei mayoral candidate Shen Boyang of the Democratic Progressive Party conducted street sweeps in a motorcade in Da'an and Wenshan District today, and held a municipal lecture in Da'an Forest Park in the evening. There was a large crowd at the scene, and the number of people online at the same time exceeded 120,000. Well-known designer Nie Yongzhen also came to support.

自由时报
2 min read
Shen Boyang was shocked to sing "I'm not afraid of the rolling white waves" when 50,000 water droplets poured onto the stage at Da'an Forest Park.
BREAKING·

Shen Boyang was shocked to sing "I'm not afraid of the rolling white waves" when 50,000 water droplets poured onto the stage at Da'an Forest Park.

Taipei mayoral candidate Shen Boyang of the Democratic Progressive Party held a campaign event in Daan Forest Park. More than 50,000 supporters flocked to the event, and 100,000 people watched online. Shen Boyang arrived at the scene surrounded by crowds. Hosts Wu Siyao and Wu Zheng expressed surprise at the grand occasion.

自由时报
2 min read
Lai Ruilong and Zhang Hanzhong competed for the founding meeting of the President. Chairs passed by Ke Zhien and Li Yajing in front of the presidential election. Li Yajing angrily criticized arrogance and arrogance!
BREAKING·

Lai Ruilong and Zhang Hanzhong competed for the founding meeting of the President. Chairs passed by Ke Zhien and Li Yajing in front of the presidential election. Li Yajing angrily criticized arrogance and arrogance!

Democratic Progressive Party Kaohsiung mayoral candidate Lai Ruilong and Assemblyman Zhang Hanzhong held a campaign headquarters inauguration meeting in Fengshan. Because the seats were placed in front of the KMT candidates Ke Zhien and Li Yajing's presidential race, Li Yajing was dissatisfied and questioned the DPP's arrogance. The police deployed police to build a human wall to prevent conflicts.

自由时报
1 min read
Ko Wenzhe sweeps the streets at Pingtung Night Market to solicit votes, boosting the People's Party's election sentiment
BREAKING·

Ko Wenzhe sweeps the streets at Pingtung Night Market to solicit votes, boosting the People's Party's election sentiment

Former Taiwan People's Party Chairman Ko Wenzhe went to Pingtung National Night Market to sweep the streets tonight to canvass votes for party candidates Lin Yu-hsien and Guo Tai'an. Ko Wenzhe expressed his appreciation for the enthusiasm of the people in Pingtung and said he hoped that the People's Party's candidates in Pingtung could hit a home run.

自由时报
2 min read
More on this topic蔣萬安