Breaking
CNMagnitude 7.7 earthquake hits Panama, triggering tsunami warning along eastern Pacific coastBRPan-American canoeing champion Rie Nagasako dies after drowning in RioTREnergy move by Trump and Putin: Millions of tons of diesel will be released to the marketBRDriver dies after crashing a truck into a trailer and one of the vehicles catching fire in the interior of SPBRPanama earthquake: VIDEO shows bridge cables moving during tremorRUKatie Zakaria could be the new White House press secretaryTRTerrible accident in Gaziantep! A car and a minibus carrying agricultural workers collided: There are dead and injuredRUPutin and Trump hold phone talks – KremlinBRTruck loaded with pine overturns and closes Raposo Tavares in AngatubaKRRain in the southern region and Jeju on Saturday… Jeju up to 50㎜CNMagnitude 7.7 earthquake hits Panama, triggering tsunami warning along eastern Pacific coastBRPan-American canoeing champion Rie Nagasako dies after drowning in RioTREnergy move by Trump and Putin: Millions of tons of diesel will be released to the marketBRDriver dies after crashing a truck into a trailer and one of the vehicles catching fire in the interior of SPBRPanama earthquake: VIDEO shows bridge cables moving during tremorRUKatie Zakaria could be the new White House press secretaryTRTerrible accident in Gaziantep! A car and a minibus carrying agricultural workers collided: There are dead and injuredRUPutin and Trump hold phone talks – KremlinBRTruck loaded with pine overturns and closes Raposo Tavares in AngatubaKRRain in the southern region and Jeju on Saturday… Jeju up to 50㎜
BackNetanyahu's former military aide reveals a surprise regarding warnings that preceded the October 7 attack
Netanyahu's former military aide reveals a surprise regarding warnings that preceded the October 7 attack
Developing
CNN بالعربية1 hour agoWorld2 min readArgentinaView original

Netanyahu's former military aide reveals a surprise regarding warnings that preceded the October 7 attack

Quick Look

Avi Gil, a former military aide to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said that the Israeli security establishment received internal warnings about the possibility of war before the October 7 attacks, and that there were huge gaps between what the public knew and what actually happened, adding that he woke Netanyahu on the morning of the attack and told him that Israel was at war.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

Avi Gil was Benjamin Netanyahu's military secretary from July 2021 to May 2024, attending security cabinet meetings and receiving sensitive security reports. He was the one who woke up Netanyahu on the morning of the October 7 attack across the security red line.

Font size

(CNN) - A former senior aide to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that the Israeli leader received internal warnings about the possibility of war before the October 7 attacks, and that there are still “huge gaps” between what the public knows and what actually happened, in an interview that included dangerous statements.

It was Major General Avi Gil who woke up the Israeli Prime Minister on the morning of the bloodiest attacks in the country's history. His statements increase the pressure on Netanyahu, a few weeks before crucial elections that will determine his political future.

Speaking to the Israeli “News 12” channel, Gil, who served as Netanyahu’s military secretary from July 2021 to May 2024, said, “For weeks, documents have been presented, and the security establishment has been describing a reality in which our enemies recognize the divisions within Israeli society as a point of weakness, and see an erosion in Israel’s ability to deter.”

Gale explained that there was no specific warning about a large-scale attack emanating from Gaza, but he noted that the Israeli security establishment was aware that the state’s opponents viewed the protests sweeping the country and the growing divisions within society as an opportunity.

Gil said: “Have we begun to observe, within the security establishment, an erosion of deterrence and a change in our enemies’ view of the State of Israel? The definitive answer is yes, and all levels have been informed of this.”

This direct testimony adds to a growing body of reports that Netanyahu received warnings, both general and specific, about the possibility of a Hamas attack from Gaza in the weeks and months leading up to October 7, 2023.

The Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported in early September that Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, President of the United Arab Emirates, called Netanyahu directly and warned him of a major operation planned by Hamas, just a few days before the attack. In the same period, The Atlantic magazine reported that the head of Egyptian intelligence at the time, Abbas Kamel, personally traveled to Israel to inform Netanyahu that Hamas was preparing to launch a major attack. Netanyahu denied these reports, describing what was published by the newspaper "Haaretz" as an "absolute lie."

But Gale's account differs from previous reports, because it comes from within the highest levels of the Israeli government. As Netanyahu's military secretary, Gil attended meetings of the security cabinet alongside the prime minister, and was privy to important communications before the outbreak of war.

It was Gil who called Netanyahu and woke him up on the morning of the attack, before communicating with him via the secure “red line,” a phone designated for secret communications. He says that at 6:41 a.m., 12 minutes after the Hamas-led attack began, he told Netanyahu clearly and categorically: “We are in a state of war.”

In response to the interview, Netanyahu issued a statement saying: “Like others, Avi Gil was aware of the impending attack and chose not to wake the prime minister in time. Gil’s interviews are nothing but attempts to obscure the simple and painful truth about his failure to carry out his duties.”

Opposition politicians launched a scathing attack on Netanyahu following the interview, demanding that the government's attorney general investigate Gale's allegations. Gadi Eisenkot, Netanyahu's main rival and former chief of staff of the Israeli army, said: "The truth about the October 7 attack is not Netanyahu's private property; the Israeli public has the right to know the whole truth, conduct a comprehensive investigation into responsibilities, and seek justice."

Like the head of the Israeli military unit responsible for the hostage file, Gale stated that Netanyahu valued the stability of his government over the return of the hostages, including those who could have returned alive to their homes. Gale noted that Netanyahu may have been inclined to agree to previous deals to release the hostages, but far-right ministers in his government convinced him otherwise.

“Bereaved families come to me and I sit with them,” he said. “There is a term used which is ‘survivors’, which I find appalling when I sit across from people who have come back from that hell. And yes, you realize that some of them could have come home sooner.”

Gil also noted that there are "huge gaps" between what the Israeli public knows about what happened before and after October 7, and what actually happened.

Netanyahu had submitted a lengthy response to Israel's oversight body regarding his actions related to the October 7 attack, but Gale claimed that the document "reflects only part of the picture."

He said: "What I saw does not faithfully reflect everything that was said in those discussions; in fact, it does not even reflect half of the picture. I am talking about lies, half-truths, and things that do not reflect what I witnessed during my time as military secretary."

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • An official investigation will be opened into Avi Gil's allegations about warnings prior to the October 7 attack

    Likely · Within weeks

  • The pressure on Netanyahu will increase before the upcoming crucial elections

    Very likely · Within days

Open Questions

  • Why were no preventive measures taken despite internal warnings?
  • What are the exact contents of the warnings received by the security establishment?
  • Will this revelation lead to an official investigation into the responsibilities of Netanyahu and the security establishment?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by CNN بالعربية.

Related Stories

6 wounded in an Israeli attack in northeastern Lebanon
Developing·

6 wounded in an Israeli attack in northeastern Lebanon

Palestinian officials announced the postponement of the legislative and presidential elections scheduled for November 2024 due to the lack of political, security and economic conditions, while Lebanese Prime Minister Nawaf Salam stressed the necessity of comprehensive reform to restore state sovereignty, and thousands of Syrians in Al-Hasakah Governorate held massive demonstrations demanding the imposition of state sovereignty and the release of detainees held by the dissolved Syrian Democratic Forces.

الشرق الأوسط
3 min read
More on this topicAvi Gale