
The Supreme Court of Russia confirmed the legality of the decision of the High Qualification Board of Judges to agree to initiate a criminal case against the judge of the Kyzyl City Court Aziyana Mongush, suspected of issuing a deliberately unjust judicial act with fictitious data about the court hearing.
AI-generated summary
Judge Aziyana Mongush from the Kyzyl City Court issued a ruling in which she pointed to a fictitious court hearing, where, allegedly at the request of the state prosecutor, it was decided to suspend the proceedings and change the measure of restraint for the defendant to detention with a search. This raised suspicions of a deliberately unfair judicial act.
Brief retelling from RIA II
The Supreme Court of Russia recognized as legal the decision to give consent to initiate a criminal case against judge Aziyana Mongush.
In July, the High Qualification Board of Judges agreed to initiate a criminal case against Judge Mongush due to suspicions of issuing a deliberately unfair judicial act.
Judge Mongush issued a ruling with information about a fictitious court hearing, at which, allegedly at the request of the state prosecutor, a decision was made to suspend the proceedings and change the measure of restraint for the defendant.
MOSCOW, October 12 - RIA Novosti. The Supreme Court of Russia recognized as legal the decision to give consent to initiate a criminal case against the judge of the Kyzyl City Court, Aziyana Mongush, who was suspected of issuing an order to arrest the defendant without a court hearing, the department’s press service reported.
In July, the High Qualification Board of Judges agreed to initiate a criminal case against Judge Mongush due to suspicions of issuing a deliberately unfair judicial act. The judge challenged the decision in the Supreme Court.
“The highest court recognized the contested decision as legal and justified,” the statement said.
According to the Supreme Court, Mongush issued a resolution with information about a fictitious court hearing, at which, allegedly at the request of the state prosecutor, a decision was made to suspend the proceedings and change the measure of restraint for the defendant to detention and putting her on the wanted list. The appeal overturned this decision, citing gross violations of procedural law.
Mongush admitted that she made a mistake and negligence, for which she has already been disciplined. At the same time, the judge stated that the attempt to criminally prosecute her was related to her professional activities, but could not confirm this.

The defense of former director Oleg Gazmanov Dmitry Tsarenko appealed the verdict for fraud with the artist’s concert funds in the amount of 10.4 million rubles, insisting on his acquittal. Tsarenko was sentenced to 4 years in prison, later increased to 7 years in conjunction with another case. He did not admit guilt, claiming that he transferred the money to Gazmanov in full on his instructions for tax optimization.

The court in Shcherbinka invalidated the agreement dated September 14, 2013 between Yuri Shatunov and Andrei Razin on the transfer of rights to works, name, image and personal data. After Shatunov's death in 2022, the rights to the musical group 'Tender May' passed to his widow Svetlana Shatunova, who challenged the agreement in court. The lawyer stated that Razin used a fake document, adding additional pages with non-existent rights to the real agreement.

The capital's courts recognized as unreliable the documents on the basis of which producer Andrei Razin claimed rights to the songs of the group "Tender May", trademarks and the image of Yuri Shatunov, the lawyer of the singer's widow Asel Mukhtarova-Kazarnovskaya told TASS.

The Moscow City Court sentenced Elvira Smirnova to four years in prison and a fine of 1.5 million rubles in the case of supplying low-quality dry rations to the army. She admitted guilt and testified against General Dmitry Bulgakov and other defendants in the case.

Ekaterina Portnyagina’s defense filed an appeal against the sentence, according to which she was sentenced to 8 years in prison, deferred until the child reaches 14 years of age. Previously, the court found her and her husband, Dmitry Portnyagin, guilty of money laundering.

Russian President Vladimir Putin reappointed Mikhail Ptitsyn to the post of chairman of the Moscow City Court. Ptitsyn will hold this position for the next six years.