Breaking
CNThe Yunlin ship used water cannon to drive away the Chinese fishing boat. The cockpit of the Golden Shark was completely destroyed and flooded and paralyzed.RUIn Kyzyl, the Nikolai Gastello National Park was closed due to a brown bearBRDelegate Caveira is the federal deputy with the most votes in Pará in the 2026 electionsCNA 34-year-old female real estate agent in California was arrested at Los Angeles Airport on suspicion of spying on Lai Qingde’s son for the CCP.USBraves pitchers shine as Brewers take 2-0 NLDS lead with walk-off winINRussian strikes kill one, injure six in Kharkiv; drone hits Kyiv bridge as German Chancellor visitsCNThe 2026 "Jianhu" Power Surfboard Grand Prix and National Fitness Series kicked off in Keqiao, ShaoxingCNChinese Professional Baseball League Post-season Challenge starts on October 9th CITIC Brothers vs. Unified Lions Taiwan Contest TicketsBRResults of the state elections in Santa Catarina define the 40 Alesc deputies for 2027RUTürkiye will remain an expensive destination for Russian tourists next yearCNThe Yunlin ship used water cannon to drive away the Chinese fishing boat. The cockpit of the Golden Shark was completely destroyed and flooded and paralyzed.RUIn Kyzyl, the Nikolai Gastello National Park was closed due to a brown bearBRDelegate Caveira is the federal deputy with the most votes in Pará in the 2026 electionsCNA 34-year-old female real estate agent in California was arrested at Los Angeles Airport on suspicion of spying on Lai Qingde’s son for the CCP.USBraves pitchers shine as Brewers take 2-0 NLDS lead with walk-off winINRussian strikes kill one, injure six in Kharkiv; drone hits Kyiv bridge as German Chancellor visitsCNThe 2026 "Jianhu" Power Surfboard Grand Prix and National Fitness Series kicked off in Keqiao, ShaoxingCNChinese Professional Baseball League Post-season Challenge starts on October 9th CITIC Brothers vs. Unified Lions Taiwan Contest TicketsBRResults of the state elections in Santa Catarina define the 40 Alesc deputies for 2027RUTürkiye will remain an expensive destination for Russian tourists next year
BackDebates on Respect for Democracy, the Ballot Box and the Result and Democratic Tensions in Türkiye
Debates on Respect for Democracy, the Ballot Box and the Result and Democratic Tensions in Türkiye
Developing
Cumhuriyet2 hours agoPolitics3 min readTürkiyeView original

Debates on Respect for Democracy, the Ballot Box and the Result and Democratic Tensions in Türkiye

Quick Look

  • In Türkiye, there are discussions about respect for election results, democratic principles and ballot box security.
  • The operations and member transfers carried out by the government in municipalities where the opposition won the local elections are criticized.
  • Developments in Mersin, Istanbul's Üsküdar, Eyüpsultan and Ataşehir municipalities and the decrease in the CHP's membership gap in the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Assembly are on the agenda.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

There are operations and member transfers by the government in some municipalities where the opposition won after the local elections in Türkiye. This situation leads to debates about democratic principles and respect for ballot box results.

Font size

We are facing a very serious test in terms of democracy. One of the most basic principles is on the risk line: “Respect for the ballot box and the outcome”.

The right to vote and be elected and the ballot box, which is indispensable for the reflection of the will of the nation, and the issue of respect for the result are being drawn into a great debate. Since we cannot say "the ballot box is guilty", a clear, non-partisan stance against wrongdoings is essential. But the "buts" do not end; The erosion of democratic, secular and rule of law principles continues.

We are all watching a strange "transfer journey" on behalf of the ruling party in places where the opposition won the local elections. While we are talking about the absolute nullity of the CHP, the dissolution of the party, and the full-throated pressure on the NEW Party, there is no end to the controversial arrests, dawn operations, the submission of those with "full baggage" to the government, partisan/rental relations, and members/presidents switching from the party they were elected to the diametrically opposite party. As the operations and "transfers" become more frequent and become dangerously ordinary, it seems that the person who reverses his voting address has crossed the line of shame.

The last stop in the operations against the opposition-held metropolitan municipalities was Mersin last week. In some comments, it was claimed that the aim was to prevent Vahap Seçer from a possible presidential candidacy. While the attitude towards Üsküdar Municipality, which is incompatible with democratic principles, was being discussed in Istanbul, Eyüpsultan and Ataşehir were added to the new waves. Claims that the stones of the process are being laid towards IMM are increasing.

It is pointed out that the difference between CHP and "Cumhur" members in the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Assembly has decreased to 12. So, is it possible for a government that "turned" municipalities to itself through non-ballot means, describe this as a success story and not see the social reaction? Can the fact that it sees and continues to be explained within the framework of the principle of respect for democratic principles and the will of the voters?... Can a culture of democracy be built by creating a "controlled opposition"?

Turkey's journey to democracy has never been easy. But despite all the difficulties, a strong stance was always taken to respect the will of the ballot box. It should not be forgotten that voters will hold accountable those who erode this will at the ballot box. In the climate of constant pressure, voters should not be alienated from the ballot box by thinking that somehow their will is not respected. Undoubtedly, in participatory, pluralistic democracies, going to the polls alone is not enough. Otherwise, there are many examples of countries that say, "I established the ballot box, I won" and that do not pass the edge of democracy. It is necessary to ensure that the opportunity to elect/be elected the government/opposition within the framework of constitutional fundamental rights and freedoms, to campaign in every region of the country, and to comply with the principle of separation of powers; not allowing a climate of oppression and fear; Voter participation and ballot box security.

Crisis topics on the country's agenda are quite heavy. While the rebellion of retirees and workers echoes in the squares, all eyes are on whether accountability will be equal for everyone in the huge fund robbery in which important names of the government are involved. Just like how the equation between power/supporter closeness and acquittal will result.

It is difficult to keep up with the speed of operations. But from "fund" scandals to green fields, corruption, corruption and ethical/moral erosion are obvious. Undoubtedly, those who are involved in specific crimes must first be brought to justice, but shouldn't the system that allows this dirty climate be questioned?...

IT SHOULD NOT BE DRAWN INTO THE YEMEN CRISIS

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • CHP's membership difference in the Istanbul Metropolitan Municipality Assembly may decrease further and this may create difficulties in management.

    Possible · Within weeks

  • Operations and transfers in municipalities where the opposition won in local elections may continue, leading to further legal and political disputes.

    Likely · Within months

Open Questions

  • On what legal basis are these operations and transfers carried out?
  • How common is the idea that the will of the voters is not respected?
  • How will this process affect the reliability of the democratic system?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by Cumhuriyet.

Related Stories

Özgür Özel will begin his term as CHP Chairman, Ministers will attend international meetings, Turkish Statistical Institute will announce September inflation.
Developing·

Özgür Özel will begin his term as CHP Chairman, Ministers will attend international meetings, Turkish Statistical Institute will announce September inflation.

CHP New Party Chairman Özgür Özel will start the Central Executive Board meeting at the party headquarters. Minister of Family and Social Services Mahinur Özdemir Göktaş will attend the Ministerial Session at the International Social Responsibility Forum and hold bilateral meetings with the ministers of Singapore, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Oman and Bahrain. Minister of National Education Yusuf Tekin will visit the governorship in Hakkari and attend the Provincial Education Evaluation Meeting, visit the AK Party Provincial Headquarters and attend the Youth Meeting at the Historical Meydan Madrasa. Turkish Statistical Institute will announce inflation figures for September. The 77th International Astronautical Congress will start with a ceremony at Antalya's NEST Congress Center. The Ministry of Treasury and Finance will re-issue 2- and 5-year maturity government bonds and directly sell 2-year gold bonds and lease certificates. Minister of Foreign Affairs Hakan Fidan will attend the meeting of the Strategic Political and Defense Committee established within the scope of the Mecca Joint Defense Agreement with Minister of National Defense Yaşar Güler and Chief of General Staff General Selçuk Bayraktaroğlu. The US-Iran tension and the ceasefire process in Gaza are being followed internationally.

Bloomberg HT
1 min read
Can the Mecca Alliance Agreement be implemented without the approval of the Turkish Grand National Assembly?
Developing·

Can the Mecca Alliance Agreement be implemented without the approval of the Turkish Grand National Assembly?

It is discussed that military engagement in Yemen can be carried out without the need for Parliamentary approval of the Mecca Alliance agreement; While it is emphasized in the constitution that foreign policy agreements require the approval of the Turkish Grand National Assembly, it is stated that the agreement does not yet have an official text and is only a joint declaration.

Cumhuriyet
2 min read
Presidential Elections Have Started in Brazil, Lula and Flavio Bolsonaro are Ahead
BREAKING·

Presidential Elections Have Started in Brazil, Lula and Flavio Bolsonaro are Ahead

Approximately 159 million voters in Brazil started voting at 08:00 local time, and voting will end at 17:00. The current President, Lula da Silva, and the right-wing candidate Flavio Bolsonaro are leading. If 50%+1 votes are not received in the first round, a second round will be held on October 25. Polls show that Lula has 48% support and Flavio Bolsonaro has 43% support.

Habertürk Dünya
1 min read