Trump Administration Seeks Supreme Court Intervention on USPS Mail-in Voting Plan
Quick Look
- The Trump administration has asked the Supreme Court to lift a federal court block on a U.S.
- Postal Service plan to restrict mail-in voting for the midterm elections, which would require states to submit voter lists and use specific barcodes on ballots; key parts of the plan remain blocked by a temporary restraining order, and experts warn implementation would cause major disruptions due to untested systems and potential ballot delivery failures.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
The Trump administration issued an executive order in March directing the USPS to implement measures to restrict mail-in voting, citing concerns about illegal voting by non-U.S. citizens, despite studies showing such fraud is rare. The USPS issued a revised rule in August requiring states to submit voter lists and use specific barcodes on ballot envelopes.
The Trump administration has asked the Supreme Court to lift a block on the U.S. Postal Service plan for President Trump's attempt to restrict mail-in voting for the midterm election.
For now, key parts of that plan are blocked by a temporary restraining order from a federal judge in Boston.
As the legal fight over Trump's mail-in voting order continues, here's what to know about the state of voting by mail for the midterms:
Has the USPS plan directly changed mail-in voting for the midterms?
No, key parts of the plan, including requirements for states, are currently blocked by a court order. Voting by mail is still available to all voters who are eligible for it in their states, and USPS is expected to deliver mail-in ballots for the midterm election as usual.
How could the USPS plan change mail-in voting?
State election officials would be required to turn over lists of mail-in voters' names and addresses to USPS and have certain barcodes on their mail ballot envelopes, according to a revised rule for federal ballot mail the Postal Service issued in August. USPS says it would not deliver ballots to voters for election officials that don't meet those requirements.
When does mail-in voting start for the midterms?
North Carolina has to start mailing out its absentee ballots on Friday, which officially kicks off the voting season for this year's midterms. Many other states are set to begin sending out their mail-in ballots later this month.
Is it possible for the USPS plan to be carried out for the midterms?
Many election experts say it is too late for USPS to carry out this plan without causing major disruptions. A whistleblower report claims USPS has not properly tested the online portal system that would collect mail-in voters' information. The report also alleges the agency has set up a policy for verifying ballot envelopes that could result in many voters not getting their ballots in time for the midterm election or at all.
What are the legal arguments for and against the USPS plan?
USPS came up with this plan in response to a March executive order by President Trump, who said he issued the directives to USPS to stop illegal voting by non-U.S. citizens. Many studies and audits show, however, that problem is incredibly rare. While USPS claims its revised rule is an effort to regulate mail, challengers of the USPS plan argue it is illegal because the mailing agency has no authority to control voting by mail.
Hasn't the Supreme Court already ruled on Trump's mail-in voting order?
Yes, the Supreme Court ruled in August on a procedural question about one of the lawsuits. But so far, the justices have not ruled on the legality of the order or the USPS plan.
Editor's note: USPS is a financial supporter of NPR.
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The Supreme Court will hear arguments on whether to lift the block on the USPS mail-in voting plan
Likely · Within weeks
If the USPS plan is implemented, it will cause significant delays in mail-in ballot delivery in multiple states
Likely · Within days
Open Questions
- Will the Supreme Court grant the administration's request to lift the block on the USPS plan?
- How many voters could be affected if the USPS plan is implemented despite expert warnings?
- What specific changes will election officials need to make to comply with the USPS requirements if the block is lifted?
