X claims discovery of 200,000-account Chinese bot farm influencing US AI data center debate
Quick Look
X (formerly Twitter) reported discovering a bot farm of approximately 200,000 accounts, with 200 accounts posting content that could manipulate legitimate debate about American AI and energy policy, echoing similar claims made by OpenAI in June regarding Chinese inauthentic accounts using ChatGPT to generate anti-data center content.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
In June, OpenAI published a report stating that accounts likely based in China used ChatGPT to generate anti-data center content, including both synthetic material and legitimate news stories about power grid capacity auctions and data center power demand, suggesting involvement of a social media team at a private Chinese company working for local government clients.
Just weeks after Sam Altman's OpenAI linked China with datacentre protests across America, now the world's richest man Elon Musk's company X, formerly Twitter, has made similar claims. In a post on its platform, X said that it has discovered a bot farm network with 200,000 accounts as part of its Safety team's investigation into suspected inauthentic Chinese accounts. The company announced its findings on its Global Government Affairs page. It said that 200 accounts out of the 200,000 were posting comic strips, images and text about AI data centers in a manner that "could manipulate a legitimate debate about American AI and energy policy." In June this year, OpenAI published a report saying that accounts likely based in China used ChatGPT to generate anti-data center content. OpenAI noted back then that while the ChatGPT users likely used fake accounts to post on social media, they also posted "legitimate news stories about the power grid operator's capacity auctions and data center power demand." OpenAI believes they're part of a social media team at a private Chinese company working for local government clients. They apparently even uploaded a file to the chatbot describing their objectives and strategies on how to sway public opinion and how to establish fake social media accounts without getting detected.
What X said on Chinese bot farms fueling anti-AI data center protests
The X Safety team conducted an investigation into suspected Chinese inauthentic accounts involved in influence operations: We identified a bot farm of approximately 200,000 accounts. Within this farm, we found 200 accounts posting in a manner that could manipulate a legitimate debate about American AI and energy policy. These posts contained claims that AI data centers are driving up household electricity prices and straining the grid. Others included AI-generated cartoons that depicted data-center operators enriching themselves at the public's expense. We remain committed to maintaining an open and authentic platform where people debate topics of public interest. We take seriously any attempts to undermine the integrity of the global town square and suspend accounts that violate our Authenticity policy. Incidentally, Elon Musk’s X also shared the sample posts to make its case as in OpenAI report. The pictures, illustrations and cartoons shared by X are the same as those shared by OpenAI in its report in June. The inauthentic accounts reportedly used OpenAI to generate illustrations and make talking points for their campaign.
End of Article
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
X will suspend or take action against the identified inauthentic accounts violating its Authenticity policy
Very likely · Within days
US government agencies may investigate the alleged Chinese influence operation targeting AI and energy policy debates
Possible · Within weeks
Open Questions
- What specific evidence does X have linking the bot farm accounts to the Chinese government?
- Are the 200,000 accounts actively operated or merely registered?
- What actions has X taken against the identified accounts beyond public disclosure?