Breaking
DEFive dead in shooting at elementary school in OregonCNEach person pays 3,000 more per year! Blue and white forced to enter the third reading of free health insurance premiums for those over 65 years oldCNSemi-conductor, minivan, minibus collided together, 4 vehicles chased each other in National 3 Ford Tunnel, 2 were injuredFRTesla Roadster: it flies, it rolls, it leaps…We tell you about the crazy presentation of Elon Musk’s sports carJPDodgers miss World Series, lose 4th straight despite Shohei Ohtani hitting a home runTRBreaking news! Critical warning from Meteorology: A new wave of rain is comingTRTürkiye decision from MSCITRMeteorology announced: Weather report for October 16, 2026... What will the weather be like today?DEStock market on October 16th: Seven points that are important for investors todayJPIf a child falls off a bicycle, it can cause serious internal injuries... Be careful of "handlebar trauma"DEFive dead in shooting at elementary school in OregonCNEach person pays 3,000 more per year! Blue and white forced to enter the third reading of free health insurance premiums for those over 65 years oldCNSemi-conductor, minivan, minibus collided together, 4 vehicles chased each other in National 3 Ford Tunnel, 2 were injuredFRTesla Roadster: it flies, it rolls, it leaps…We tell you about the crazy presentation of Elon Musk’s sports carJPDodgers miss World Series, lose 4th straight despite Shohei Ohtani hitting a home runTRBreaking news! Critical warning from Meteorology: A new wave of rain is comingTRTürkiye decision from MSCITRMeteorology announced: Weather report for October 16, 2026... What will the weather be like today?DEStock market on October 16th: Seven points that are important for investors todayJPIf a child falls off a bicycle, it can cause serious internal injuries... Be careful of "handlebar trauma"
Newsgather
All StoriesWorldSportsFinanceTechScienceHealthCultureClimatePoliticsSpace
Back黃國昌批涉毒檢安全下莊 劍青檢改搬「柯文哲語錄」反擊
黃國昌批涉毒檢安全下莊 劍青檢改搬「柯文哲語錄」反擊
Developing
自由时报2 hours agoLaw2 min readChinaView translation

黃國昌批涉毒檢安全下莊 劍青檢改搬「柯文哲語錄」反擊

劍青檢改柯文哲黃國昌

Quick Look

台北地檢署劉姓檢察官因涉毒初犯態度良好獲緩起訴，民眾黨主席黃國昌批檢方包庇遮醜。劍青檢改聲明反擊，引用柯文哲「把吸毒的人當成病人，而不是犯人」語錄，指出緩起訴戒癮治療需自費就醫、定期報到驗尿，違規將面臨撤銷或入監，質疑黃國昌言論是愚蠢無知或惡意煽動對立，並強調該政策實施逾18年，初犯獲緩起訴比率超過70%。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

緩起訴戒癮治療政策在台灣已實施逾18年，初犯涉毒者若符合條件可獲緩起訴，需自費就醫、定期報到驗尿，違規將面臨撤銷或入監。

Font size

劍青檢改引用柯文哲「把吸毒的人當成病人，而不是犯人」語錄，反擊黃國昌批評檢方給予涉毒檢察官緩起訴是「包庇遮醜」。（資料照）

台北地檢署劉姓檢察官涉毒因初犯、且態度良好獲緩起訴，但民眾黨主席黃國昌卻批檢方包庇遮醜、讓人安全下莊。檢察官改革團體「劍青檢改」今聲明，緩起訴戒癮治療仍須自費就醫、定期報到驗尿，怒斥黃「若非愚蠢無知，就是惡意煽動對立」，並引用柯文哲「把吸毒的人當成病人，而不是犯人」語錄反擊。

劍青檢改指出，柯文哲2018年6月出席「北極星反毒計畫暨台北市毒品危害防制中心」記者會時曾說：「因為我是醫生，我們看待事情的視角會不一樣，大家要改變觀念，把吸毒的人當成『病人』，而不是『犯人』。」

請繼續往下閱讀...

同年8月，柯出席「成癮及酒駕醫療介入活動」再度強調，不能單純把酒癮、藥癮者當犯人，要當病人處理，長期效果會比較好；成癮問題單靠司法或警察抓人沒有用，關出來後復發率仍高，必須由衛生、社政、司法、警政及醫療單位共同介入，透過醫療處遇降低再犯。劍青檢改以此呼籲黃國昌遵循柯的主張，回歸「科學理性務實」。

針對黃國昌將緩起訴戒癮治療批為「安全下莊」，劍青檢改說，「若非愚蠢無知，就是惡意煽動對立」。聲明指出，被告在緩起訴監督期間，必須全程自費門診，定期向觀護人報到、驗尿，一旦違規，將面臨撤銷緩起訴、觀察勒戒或入監服刑，並非獲得緩起訴就沒事。

劍青檢改表示，緩起訴戒癮治療政策已實施逾18年，初犯獲緩起訴戒癮治療比率超過70%；若扣除已在監執行、羈押、另犯暴力重罪、重病不便、拒不出庭或拒絕認罪者，比率更近80%。考量在於被告是否表達意願、同意全程配合並全額自費，不因職業、貧富、貴賤而有差別，「因為成癮者需要的是治療，與其職業無關」。

劍青檢改質疑，增加管制與監督的公衛制度，為何到了黃國昌口中，就成了「包庇遮醜」、「安全下莊」？究竟是愚蠢無知，還是惡意帶風向攻擊檢方，連帶污衊公衛制度？

聲明最後強調，台灣需要更安全、更具醫療人權、能有效降低再犯率的犯罪防治政策及公衛制度，不應縱容惡意汙蔑、混淆視聽、製造對立與仇恨的態度；任何試圖激化仇恨、分化社會的政客言論，都應被譴責、唾棄，「被拋棄到歷史的灰燼中」。

☆少一份毒品就多一份健康，自由時報提醒您遠離毒品☆

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • 黃國昌將針對劍青檢改的聲明發表進一步說明或回應

    Likely · Within days

Open Questions

  • 黃國昌是否會回應劍青檢改的質疑？
  • 緩起訴戒癮治療的實際再犯率是多少？
  • 是否有其他政治人物支持或反對此政策？

Related Topics

劍青檢改
People柯文哲黃國昌劉姓檢察官
Organizations台北地檢署民眾黨
Places台北台灣
Topics柯文哲黃國昌緩起訴戒癮治療涉毒檢察官台北地檢署
This article was originally published by 自由时报.

Related Stories

In the New Taipei Junior High School student’s neck-slitting case, lawyer Gan Ge said the victim’s family donated money to pretend to be poor, and the firm was renamed after losing one star
Developing·

In the New Taipei Junior High School student’s neck-slitting case, lawyer Gan Ge said the victim’s family donated money to pretend to be poor, and the firm was renamed after losing one star

The civil damages lawsuit for the neck-cutting case of a junior high school student in New Taipei City is still under trial. Defense lawyer Lin Yuexue questioned the victim's family's donation of 5 million yuan as a scholarship and bursary as a "deliberate transfer of assets." He publicly insulted the victim's family lawyer Li Huixuan for the second time as a "shame on the legal profession." This triggered netizens to search the bottom of the website, spoof his law firm, and flooded it with one-star negative reviews, and even renamed it "Lin Yuexue Parking Lot" on Google Maps.

自由时报
2 min read
Fake experts sit in court, fake buyers collect "deposits", and the court reveals old fraud routines
Law·

Fake experts sit in court, fake buyers collect "deposits", and the court reveals old fraud routines

The Xicheng District People's Court of Beijing released typical cases involving the protection of the rights and interests of the elderly and disclosed two fraud cases targeting the elderly: one involved health care fraud, in which the defendants Li and Yang attracted the elderly with free activities, health lectures, etc., and fabricated their medical conditions to induce them to buy products at high prices, defrauding 8 people of more than 170,000 yuan; the other was a collectibles fraud, in which the defendants Yue and Yang posed as intermediaries and buyers, charging traceability fees and other fees under the guise of high-priced repurchases, defrauding 6 people of more than 220,000 yuan. After the trial, the court held that the defendant's behavior constituted a crime of fraud, and sentenced nine people including Yang to fixed-term imprisonment of six months to four years and eight months. Yue and Yang were each sentenced to three years and nine months and fined 35,000 yuan. The defendant has fully refunded the compensation, and all the victims' economic losses have been recovered.

中国新闻网
2 min read
First Case in Judicial History" Prosecutor's Drug Abuse, Serious Case, Submitted for Evaluation
Law·

First Case in Judicial History" Prosecutor's Drug Abuse, Serious Case, Submitted for Evaluation

Prosecutor Liu Zhonglin of the Taipei District Prosecutor's Office was suspended from prosecution by the New Taipei District Prosecutor's Office for allegedly using the second-level drug amphetamine. During the period, he received addiction treatment for six months. This was the first case in the history of our country's judicial history that an active prosecutor was involved in drug abuse. When the Beijing Prosecutor's Office learned of the case, he made an inquiry, and Liu immediately resigned. He is currently on leave and suspended from his duties. The case letter was sent to the Prosecutor Evaluation Committee for individual case evaluation.

自由时报
2 min read
Meifu Warehouse Fire Lasted for 21 Days, Lost the First Trial Appeal for Compensation of RMB 43.86 Million
Law·

Meifu Warehouse Fire Lasted for 21 Days, Lost the First Trial Appeal for Compensation of RMB 43.86 Million

In 2022, a fire at the Meifu warehouse in Taoyuan lasted for 21 days, and Zhengxian Company filed a lawsuit for more than 43.86 million yuan in compensation because the goods were burned. The Taipei District Court held that the cause of the fire could not be confirmed, and there was no way to prove that it could be blamed on the manager. It ruled that Meifu Warehouse was exempt from compensation and the entire case could be appealed.

自由时报
2 min read
The Political Yuan revised the organizational law of the courts and added judicial affairs offices and appointed guardians to the High People's Procuratorate.
Law·

The Political Yuan revised the organizational law of the courts and added judicial affairs offices and appointed guardians to the High People's Procuratorate.

On the 15th, the Executive Yuan passed the draft amendments to some provisions of the Court Organization Law and related schedules drafted by the Judicial Yuan, and will be sent to the Legislative Yuan for review. This amendment aims to solve the huge caseload and manpower scheduling difficulties by adding the Judicial Affairs Office of the High Court, supervisors and assistant prosecutors of the High Prosecutor's Office, and integrating similar statutory posts to enhance the flexibility of manpower utilization.

自由时报
1 min read
The procuratorial organs prosecuted Yang Keqin, Zhu Xiaoqing, Wei Daiqing, Liu Yunzhou, and Ban Dairong respectively in accordance with the law.
Law·

The procuratorial organs prosecuted Yang Keqin, Zhu Xiaoqing, Wei Daiqing, Liu Yunzhou, and Ban Dairong respectively in accordance with the law.

According to the Supreme People's Procuratorate, the procuratorial organs prosecuted five officials including Yang Keqin, Zhu Xiaoqing, Wei Daiqing, Liu Yunzhou, and Ban Dairong in accordance with the law. The suspected crimes include accepting bribes, using influence to accept bribes, abuse of power, and corruption.

中国新闻网
6 min read
More on this topic劍青檢改