Breaking
KRFlights across the U.S. were 'all stopped' for 4.5 hours due to communication difficulties... Aftereffects continue (3 steps overall)SATanker crashes into cruise boat in New Orleans, 32 hospitalisedINTLFAA ground stop lifted: Why were US flights grounded, and what’s next?CNJiang Wanan’s Q&A was criticized wildly and he responded to every question: Bureau XX has clearly explained to the outside world and all of them are in compliance with the regulations.CNReuters: Huang Renxun is rumored to have had an extramarital affair with Chinese businesswoman Huang Le and once misled Huida’s legal affairs chiefARCanceling the decision to stop flights in the United States, and Trump rules out a cyber attackCNWild geese, sweet potatoes, boats...Xi Jinping's wonderful metaphor for APEC cooperationCNKaohsiung man’s car crashed into a light pole on a separation island and the cause of injury remains to be investigatedBR'Fireball', 'paint smell' and hasty evacuation: residents report moments of tension after explosion at factory in SaltoKR“Jensen Huang lied to Nvidia executives about his ‘appropriate relationship with Alice’”KRFlights across the U.S. were 'all stopped' for 4.5 hours due to communication difficulties... Aftereffects continue (3 steps overall)SATanker crashes into cruise boat in New Orleans, 32 hospitalisedINTLFAA ground stop lifted: Why were US flights grounded, and what’s next?CNJiang Wanan’s Q&A was criticized wildly and he responded to every question: Bureau XX has clearly explained to the outside world and all of them are in compliance with the regulations.CNReuters: Huang Renxun is rumored to have had an extramarital affair with Chinese businesswoman Huang Le and once misled Huida’s legal affairs chiefARCanceling the decision to stop flights in the United States, and Trump rules out a cyber attackCNWild geese, sweet potatoes, boats...Xi Jinping's wonderful metaphor for APEC cooperationCNKaohsiung man’s car crashed into a light pole on a separation island and the cause of injury remains to be investigatedBR'Fireball', 'paint smell' and hasty evacuation: residents report moments of tension after explosion at factory in SaltoKR“Jensen Huang lied to Nvidia executives about his ‘appropriate relationship with Alice’”
Back黑暗流浪者》羅大佑言論得罪了幾個族群?
黑暗流浪者》羅大佑言論得罪了幾個族群?
Developing
自由时报12 minutes agoPolitics3 min readChina

黑暗流浪者》羅大佑言論得罪了幾個族群?

Quick Look

羅大佑在廣播專訪中以子宮與生育狀態評論女性社會貢獻,並點名批評馬世芳及挑起省籍對立,同時聲稱林宅血案由美國政府所為,引發女性、音樂人與認同台灣的外省族群不滿。時事評論者質疑其言論是幫助還是傷害蔣萬安,並認為代價過大。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

羅大佑接受廣播專訪,發表關於女性社會貢獻、馬世芳、省籍對立及林宅血案的言論,引發多方批評。文章作者為時事評論者,本文經授權轉載自黑暗流浪者臉書。

Font size

我已經分不清羅大佑到底是想幫蔣萬安,還是想害他了,他這一番言論至少得罪了幾個族群:

羅大佑接受廣播專訪,一番言論至少得罪了3個族群。圖為羅大佑與唐湘龍。(圖取自YouTube)

1.首先最大宗的當然是女性族群,只要不是那種對父權習慣成自然的阿信,應該都難以忍受這種以子宮跟有沒有生小孩來判斷一個女人對社會貢獻的前現代言論。沈伯洋上艾莉莎莎節目努力破圈,盡可能讓自己被一些平常不關心政治又有一定消費力的女性客群看見,羅大佑則是以極盡性別歧視的言論得罪女性族群,尤其是住在台北市那些事業有成、經濟能力強的獨立女性,一方是精準拉票,一方則是精準敗票,一來一往後雙方差距又更小了。

2.再來是音樂人,以及對華語音樂有一些認識的人。批評女性還可以說是華國遺毒跟父權傳統等思想在作祟,點名罵馬世芳則是毫無必要的忘恩負義行為。馬世芳不僅是華語樂界備受尊崇的大前輩,啟發無數後輩的音樂之路,還是羅大佑得獎時的引薦人,為了政治立場就連基本的人情義理都不顧,這種行為當然會引起公憤,就連一些平常根本沒在談政治的人,都公開聲援馬世芳,就知道他這番話的殺傷力有多大。

3.最後則是認同台灣的前外省族群。許多外省第二代跟第三代,早已不認為自己的祖國是中國,而是強烈認同台灣,這種心境轉換在許多前殖民地跟移民社會很普遍。畢竟自己就在這片土地出生長大,與遙遠的殖民母國跟父祖輩的祖國根本沒有連結,自然而然會認同養育自己一輩子的台灣。而且這些人早已習慣民主自由的生活,不能接受被極權的中共統治,就會想要挺身守護自己的家園跟現有的生活方式。更重要的是,21世紀已經過了四分之一,台灣民主化也已30多年,早已不該繼續存在所謂省籍情結,在這種情況下還刻意挑起這種對立,尤其是從一個實際上根本不是外省人的口中說出,看在真正外省家庭出身的台灣人眼中,一定會覺得羅大佑憑什麼代言我。

沈伯洋上艾莉莎莎節目,盡可能爭取女性客群,羅大佑則是以極盡性別歧視的言論得罪女性族群。圖為沈伯洋及艾莉莎莎。(圖取自Threads)

更扯的是羅大佑居然還栽贓林宅血案是美國政府幹的,這比開地圖炮得罪人還誇張,人格到底要多卑劣才講得出這種話?

光一次公開言論就像開地圖炮一樣得罪了這麼多人,還讓自己一世英名毀於一旦(如果還有英名的話),即使目的是想挑起對立來讓選戰回到藍綠基本盤對決,代價也未免太大了點。我真的很想知道,到底是他能夠催出的基本盤比較多,還是得罪人催出的肚爛票比較多?

(作者為時事評論者)

本文經授權轉載自黑暗流浪者臉書

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • 羅大佑的言論將持續引發公眾與媒體批評,可能影響其公眾形象。

    Likely · Within days

  • 此爭議可能對蔣萬安的選情產生負面影響,因為言論被視為精準敗票。

    Possible · Within weeks

Open Questions

  • 羅大佑言論的具體內容與時間細節
  • 廣播專訪的媒體名稱與播出時間
  • 林宅血案相關指控的具體依據
  • 蔣萬安或其競選團隊對此事的回應

Related Topics

This article was originally published by 自由时报.

Related Stories

Jiang Wanan’s Q&A was criticized wildly and he responded to every question: Bureau XX has clearly explained to the outside world and all of them are in compliance with the regulations.
BREAKING·

Jiang Wanan’s Q&A was criticized wildly and he responded to every question: Bureau XX has clearly explained to the outside world and all of them are in compliance with the regulations.

On the morning of the 14th, Taipei Mayor Chiang Wanan went to the Beitou Relay Market to sweep the streets for votes. Faced with municipal disputes such as administrative neutrality, the Charis Refund Coordination Committee, and the missing construction drawings of the Kitai Da Straight, he repeatedly responded by saying that the relevant bureaus had made clear explanations and complied with the regulations. This caused Facebook fan "North Korean Defector Ice Wolf" and political worker Zhou Xuan to question his dodge.

自由时报
2 min read
China Post: Behind Huang Renxun’s loss of power, China hawks have been brewing a counterattack for a long time
Urgent·

China Post: Behind Huang Renxun’s loss of power, China hawks have been brewing a counterattack for a long time

Huida CEO Huang Renxun resigned due to an extramarital affair and the woman was suspected of being a Chinese spy. The Washington Post quoted outgoing officials as saying that National Security Advisor Rubio submitted a memo to Trump based on a CIA report, which led to Huang's loss of power. Congressional hawks are trying to include restrictions on the export of new chips to China into a major defense bill, hoping to pass it before the end of the year.

中央社
3 min read
Zhong Mingxuan shouted to Tsai Ing-wen to listen to his several years of experience. Jiang Wanan supported: Politicians should listen humbly.
Developing·

Zhong Mingxuan shouted to Tsai Ing-wen to listen to his several years of experience. Jiang Wanan supported: Politicians should listen humbly.

Internet celebrity Zhong Mingxuan issued an article in response to the controversy over Luo Dayou naming Tsai Ing-wen, Xiao Meiqin, and Chen Ju as childless. He revealed that in recent years, he has felt pressure to express himself due to political interpretation of his remarks, and he appealed to Tsai Ing-wen, hoping that the other party would listen to his experience. Taipei Mayor Chiang Wanan responded that politicians should be tolerant and listen humbly to the voices of the people. It is valuable to withstand pressure and speak the truth.

自由时报
2 min read
"Martial law is in effect? No exchange of ribbons allowed" Beijie responded
Developing·

"Martial law is in effect? No exchange of ribbons allowed" Beijie responded

The Taipei MRT Corporation clarified that on the afternoon of November 13, the Wenhu Line Science and Technology Building Station received a passenger notification that passengers were distributing election materials on the train bound for the zoo, but no violations were found during on-site inspections. The company emphasized that no martial law measures had been taken, and the rumors circulating online that "the exchange of streamers is not allowed" were false. It also reiterated that in accordance with the passenger instructions, it is prohibited to engage in electioneering or political activities within the MRT area. At the same time, it upholds administrative neutrality and will not restrict the general activities of passengers.

自由时报
2 min read
There are rumors of bribery in the West District Councilor election in Jia City. Three supporters, a father and his son, were involved in buying votes worth 1,000 yuan per vote.
Urgent·

There are rumors of bribery in the West District Councilor election in Jia City. Three supporters, a father and his son, were involved in buying votes worth 1,000 yuan per vote.

Three people named Li and his son, supporters of Chiayi City's West District municipal councilor candidate, were suspected of buying votes for NT$1,000 each since August. After the prosecutor's investigation and search, three people were detained and the other two were released on bail. The case was investigated by the Chiayi District Prosecutor's Office.

自由时报
2 min read
14 days to go until the election! Shen Boyang promotes the "Soap Box" film to urge the public: Turn issues into votes
Urgent·

14 days to go until the election! Shen Boyang promotes the "Soap Box" film to urge the public: Turn issues into votes

With 14 days left until the local election, Taipei mayoral candidate Shen Boyang of the Democratic Progressive Party has launched his latest campaign advertisement, directed by advertising director Lu Chien-chang. The advertisement focuses on soap boxes across Taipei, symbolizing that citizens are the main body of the city. Shen Boyang calls on citizens to "turn issues into votes" and says, "I will hold your issues in hand and make Taipei smooth."

自由时报
2 min read
More on this topic羅大佑