
President of the Senate speaks after criticism from PL leader, Carlos Portinho, about PEC on the age of criminal responsibility
AI-generated summary
The president of the Senate, Davi Alcolumbre, spoke after receiving criticism from the leader of the PL, Carlos Portinho, about the vote on a Proposed Amendment to the Constitution to reduce the age of criminal responsibility. Alcolumbre said he would not vote on the text because the Chamber of Deputies began the discussion before the Senate. The PL defends the reduction of the age of criminal responsibility to 14 years in cases of heinous crimes and to 16 for all other crimes.
The president of the Federal Senate, Davi Alcolumbre (União-AP), said this Wednesday (4) that he regrets that politicians promoted themselves during the elections by offending other people. Alcolumbre cited the result of the PL's first round and made his speech after receiving criticism from the leader of the Liberal Party (PL), Carlos Portinho (PL-RJ).
"Sometimes, some of our colleagues go from just debating to attacking in relation to this presidency," he said. "Unfortunately, many political actors in my country called Brazil promoted themselves and won the election by offending and attacking people."
According to him, the attacks seek to garner support from the "horrible radicalism" that exists in Brazil. Alcolumbre also said that aggression, threats and lies are prevailing.
"And to my sadness and that of millions of people, they won the elections, based on some specific agenda, whether it was against the Judiciary, whether it was against the Executive, whether it was against the president of the Federal Senate, because they cast votes in the election," said Alcolumbre.
He then criticized statements that cast doubt on the results of the elections, as Senator Flávio Bolsonaro (PL) did after the results of the second round:
"They opened the polls and they won the election, but the worst part of all this is that in the first round the electronic ballot box worked [...] it was used to elect 120 federal deputies from the party of the candidate who lost the election, it was used to elect 20 or so senators, it was used to celebrate a successful election of President Lula's opponent [...] and when it opened in the second round, the ballot box was no longer useful", said the president of the Senate.
Alcolumbre spoke after the PL leader demanded a vote this Wednesday (4) on a Proposed Amendment to the Constitution (PEC) to reduce the age of criminal responsibility. Earlier, Alcolumbre said he would not vote on the text because the Chamber began the discussion before the Senate.
Portinho criticized the decision and said that Alcolumbre was failing to comply with an agreement made between the leaders the previous day to speed up the vote on the issue. The PL defends the reduction of the age of criminal responsibility to 14 years in cases of heinous crimes and to 16 for all other crimes.
"The Senate today is subject to the Judiciary and the Chamber of Deputies. And the president of Congress, Mr. Davi, you are the president of Congress, senator. Aren't you the president of Congress, Mr. Davi? You are the president of Congress, senator! It is not the Chamber of Deputies that says how it will be, the Senate is the Upper House. You made a commitment; a commitment must be fulfilled", said Portinho.
For some of the senators, the speech was an attack on Alcolumbre's performance. Government parliamentarians defended him in speeches in the plenary.
Afterwards, Portinho responded to Alcolumbre and his colleagues' statements: "I didn't offend anyone. Much less would I offend your Excellency [Alcolumbre], much less did I deal with an electronic voting machine here", said the PL leader.
Portinho also defended Flávio's escape to the United States. He further said that none of them responded about the commitment not being fulfilled.
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The Senate will vote on the PEC on the age of criminal responsibility in the coming days.
Likely · Within days
There will be new developments regarding the reduction of the age of criminal responsibility to 14 or 16 years old.
Possible · Within weeks

Mike Johnson, Speaker of the US House of Representatives, announced that he will step down as leader of the House after Democrats gain control of both Houses of Congress. At 54 years old, he has held the position since October 2023 and is the third official in the presidential line of succession. The internal vote to choose his successor is scheduled for next Tuesday.
Midterm elections in the United States elected black, Hispanic, Muslim, indigenous and LGBTQIA+ candidates to state and federal offices, including the first openly gay senator, the first Muslim in the Senate and the first indigenous woman governor, with terms beginning in January 2027.
The president of Congress, Alcolumbre, decided not to put a proposal to a vote after consideration by the president of the Chamber of Deputies, Hugo Motta, with whom he spoke the day before. He had committed to discussing the matter when the Chamber deliberated on it.
Trump says he will probably get along with Democrats unless they want to be destructive. The NYT newspaper says voters have risen up against Trump. Democrats have a majority in the Senate with 54 elected to 44 and advance in the Chamber with 237 to 139. Rogério Marinho, from PL, launches a candidacy for the presidency of the Senate. Alcolumbre wants to vote today to reduce the age of majority. Lula did not say 'for working people, prison, for criminals, protection'.

Seven Brazilians were elected state deputies in the US midterm elections, all from the Democratic Party. Four were elected in Massachusetts (Priscila Sousa, Rita Mendes, Lorena Betts and Danillo Sena), in addition to Felipe Sousa-Lazaballet in Florida, Farley Santos in Connecticut and Elaine Marzola in Nevada.

Edinho Silva, president of the PT, meets with presidents of centrist parties to understand convergences and divergences with the Lula government. The conversations do not deal with positions at the moment, and Lula wants clarity on how much the parties will deliver for the fourth term, avoiding the 2023 negotiation model.