
Independent commission finds club guilty of inflating income by £900m through 'sham' contracts
AI-generated summary
Manchester City has been under investigation for alleged breaches of financial rules over a nine-year period. The case involves complex legal arguments regarding revenue inflation and cooperation with the league.
Manchester City are set to owe the Premier League tens of millions of pounds in compensation for legal costs after being found guilty of virtually all charges brought against them.
The Premier League announced on Tuesday that an independent commission had determined the club had artificially inflated their income by £900m over a nine-year period. The panel concluded that Manchester City had arranged “sham” contracts to boost revenues to comply with spending rules.
During the procces both sides racked up what many legal experts predict will be more than £100m in costs between them. Manchester City employed Lord Pannick KC, one of the country’s leading lawyers who has advised the former prime minister Boris Johnson, while the Premier League’s team was spearheaded by Adam Smith KC, considered one of the finest sports lawyers of his generation who has represented the league, the Football Association and Uefa in a series of cases.
The Premier League’s costs are expected to be upwards of £70m and lawyers have told the Guardian that a winning party can expect to recoup around 70% of their legal costs from the losers. That means the league could be awarded almost £50m in compensation for a case that has lasted eight years already and is still not concluded.
In a 40-page document, the independent panel explained why it found Manchester City guilty of all charges related to serious breaches of the Premier League’s financial rules and “the majority of charges in relation to its failure to cooperate with the league’s investigation”.
The commission will rule on the compensation figure once the process has been completed. Manchester City maintain their innocence, claiming in a statement that “a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists”, and intend to appeal, describing the ruling as an “opinion” that contains “clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe”. The club’s chief executive, Ferran Soriano, sent a three-minute video to club employees describing it as a “Premier League conspiracy theory”.
The commission will determine if the Premier League’s legal spending was proportionate to the case. After Everton were found guilty of profit and sustainability rule breaches in 2024, the league pushed for £4.9m in costs, but was awarded £1.7m after the club’s lawyers successfully argued the legal costs were too high. Everton lawyers had claimed the cost per document disclosed was 19 times higher for the Premier League than the club, while the cost per witness statement was five times more.
The Premier League declined to comment. Manchester City did not respond to a request for comment.
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
Manchester City will file a formal appeal against the commission's ruling.
Very likely · Within weeks

Scotland fans welcomed new manager Sebastien Pocognoli at Hampden but left disappointed after Jack Hendry's early red card led to a 3-0 defeat by Switzerland, extending Scotland's goal drought to four matches.

Real Madrid are monitoring Virgil van Dijk's situation as he approaches free agency, Bayern Munich plan to offer Michael Olise a long-term contract and are interested in Jules Kounde, while Manchester United target Jean-Philippe Mateta and plan new terms for Luke Shaw, and Tottenham Hotspur show interest in Kim Min-jae.

England defeated the Czech Republic 2-0 with Anthony Gordon scoring the opener and Harry Kane adding a second, as player ratings highlighted strong performances from Gordon (8), Trent Alexander-Arnold (7), Elliot Anderson (7), and Lewis Hall (7), while Myles Lewis-Skelly was booked and substituted at halftime.

The Premier League has confirmed Manchester City guilty of all charges related to financial rule breaches between 2009-10 and 2017-18, including sham contracts with commercial partners and failure to cooperate, with more details to follow.

England manager Sarina Wiegman has excluded Ella Toone and Chloe Kelly from the upcoming World Cup qualifying squad due to performance levels. Captain Leah Williamson returns to the 23-player roster, while Aggie Beever-Jones, Lotte Wubben-Moy, and Taylor Hinds are also out.

Fernando Alonso has committed to staying in Formula 1 with Aston Martin for at least one more year, stating that he still feels as fast as anyone and expressing faith in technical partner Adrian Newey and engine supplier Honda.