Trump excludes US media from the White House – media sues against press freedom attack
Quick Look
- US President Donald Trump has banned CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House for allegedly spreading fake news.
- Over 50 media outlets and associations support the lawsuits of the affected broadcasters and point to the First Amendment and a 1974 Supreme Court ruling on editorial freedom.
- An initial court hearing has concluded.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
Trump has banned CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House for allegedly spreading fake news. Over 50 media outlets and associations support the lawsuits, citing the First Amendment and a 1974 Supreme Court ruling on editorial freedom.
With his exclusion of several US media outlets from the White House, President Trump is causing an outcry in the press landscape.
Media protests against banning of CNN and Co. (archive image) Photo: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP/dpa
Washington. Dozens of associations and media organizations have sided with the media companies banned by US President Donald Trump in court. “The government’s actions are contradictory to the First Amendment, and the newsroom exclusion must be immediately reversed,” it said in a letter to the court.
The aforementioned constitutional amendment places freedom of speech and the press under special protection. Over 50 media and associations have signed the letter.
CNN, MS NOW and “Politico” are suing against the exclusion
On Friday, Trump announced that he would withdraw access to the White House from the three media outlets CNN, MS NOW and “Politico” with immediate effect. The US President accused them of spreading fake news. Critics see this as an attempt at intimidation and an attack on press freedom. The three media companies are suing against their banishment.
The signatories of the letter justify their position, among other things, with a ruling by the Supreme Court from 1974. The judges stated in it: How and to what extent a medium reports on public figures - "whether unfairly or justly" - is fundamentally the subject of protected editorial freedom.
Court hearing
Trump has made it clear that he has banned the media because of alleged false reporting. This makes it clear that this is impermissible discrimination based on reported content. This violates decades of Supreme Court case law.
Meanwhile, a first court hearing came to an end in Washington, in which the parties to the conflict were able to describe their point of view. Trump had already made public his expectation that he would be defeated in the first instance.
Published according to the editorial standards of the Handelsblatt. You can find more information in our guidelines.
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The court will rule in favor of the media and lift the exclusion.
Likely · Within weeks
Open Questions
- How will the court decide on the lawsuits?
- Will Trump challenge the decision if he loses?
- Which other media could be affected?
