The first debate of the Taipei mayoral election was held today (31st), attracting attention from all walks of life. Many people found that the current mayor Jiang Wanan frequently lowered his head to read the manuscript during the debate, and some people even questioned Jiang Wanan for getting the topic in advance. In this regard, the famous doctor Du Chengzhe specifically used AI to count the number of times Jiang Wanan and Democratic Progressive Party candidate Shen Boyang looked down at their notes, and made a quantitative chart. It can be seen that Jiang Wanan's frequency of reading manuscripts was much higher than that of Shen Boyang.
At today's debate, you can see that Jiang Wanan frequently lowered his head and looked at the manuscript in his hand, whether he was making arguments or cross-examination, especially during the final question-and-answer session by media members. After the show ended, it was reported on the Internet that Jiang Wanan had received the questions given by the organizer in advance so that he could answer the questions smoothly after reading the manuscript. TVBS, one of the organizers, has responded to this, admitting that the questions were given in advance, but the candidates from both camps were given them, and there was no preference for either side.
Du Chengzhe specifically used Claude to count the number of times Jiang Wanan and Shen Boyang looked down at their notes when answering questions from Fan Qiming, the deputy news manager of the T station, made a quantitative chart, and asked it to answer "who is more likely to read the entire paragraph." Claude answered this way: "The number of times will fluctuate according to the judgment threshold, Jiang Wanan's 59-65 times, Shen Boyang's 18-24 times. No matter how the threshold is adjusted, the gap is about 3 times. As for who is more like the entire reading draft, that is Jiang Wanan."
Claude further analyzed the action pattern and said that Jiang Wanan's reading rhythm was very regular. He lowered his head for 1 second and then raised his head to speak a sentence. This was a typical pattern of "reading one sentence and speaking one sentence" reading the manuscript sentence by sentence. Shen Boyang lowered his head as if he was checking the key points. He didn't look at the first paragraph until he reached a paragraph. In the second half, he almost didn't look at the notes and kept looking ahead. In terms of language characteristics, Claude said that Jiang Wanan's speech was like a completely written article, while Shen Boyang's speech was more like improvising with an outline because there were many redundant words in his spoken language.
Du Chengzhe finally said, "The questions are provided in advance. If you prepare in advance, there is no problem. But it makes people feel that this person does not need to know how to do these things. He only needs to read it from beginning to end."
Netizens left comments, "No matter how well packaged it is, the secret will always be exposed.", "You can tell who is the robot if you watch the whole process.", "The part where the media asked questions was really ugly. The questions were leaked on the catwalk, and the manuscripts were already there. I didn't memorize them seriously. I kept looking down at the manuscripts. Think everyone is blind?", "One is that you don't even memorize the manuscripts carefully. It's like the whole mind has been hollowed out, Tianlong National Intelligence Test", "There is another important point. Jiang Bao always says at the beginning, "Actually, you don't understand municipal affairs." How many times has this sentence been repeated throughout the debate?", "He knows that he is memorizing the manuscript, and we also know that he is memorizing the manuscript. He knows that he is memorizing the manuscript, and he also knows that we know that he is memorizing the manuscript, but he is still memorizing the manuscript." "The puppet does not need to know why this line or that line is mentioned. He only needs to cooperate with the performance to make the audience think that the puppet is alive."
