Back蔣萬安指沈伯洋主張瑞士醫療海洛因 張景森駁斥:沒說過的話別塞嘴巴
蔣萬安指沈伯洋主張瑞士醫療海洛因 張景森駁斥:沒說過的話別塞嘴巴
Politics
自由时报1 hour agoPolitics3 min readChinaView translation

蔣萬安指沈伯洋主張瑞士醫療海洛因 張景森駁斥:沒說過的話別塞嘴巴

台北市長蔣萬安近期頻攻民進黨參選人毒品議題,指張景森文章稱沈伯洋主張瑞士醫療用海洛因。張景森下午發文駁斥,強調「瑞士有這種制度」與「沈伯洋主張瑞士模式」完全是兩回事。

Quick Look

台北市長蔣萬安指張景森文章稱沈伯洋主張瑞士醫療用海洛因。張景森下午發文駁斥,強調「瑞士有這種制度」與「沈伯洋主張瑞士模式」完全是兩回事,要求「沒說過的話不要塞到我的嘴巴裡」。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

爭論源於沈伯洋2014年文章,提及台灣若無法接受毒品除罪化,可仿效特定國家建立社區中心提供吸毒者協助。

Font size

台北市長蔣萬安近期頻攻民進黨台北市長參選人毒品議題,今(6)日上午蔣說,有看到也看到前行政院政委張景森說,沈伯洋主張的是瑞士醫療用的海洛因,他看完文章也是這樣的認知。

張景森今下午駁斥,他沒說過這樣的話,不該這樣解讀,「瑞士有這種制度」與「沈伯洋當年主張的就是瑞士模式」,完全是兩件事。討論公共政策有一個最基本的前提:先把別人的話講對,「我沒有說過的話,不要塞到我的嘴巴」。

張景森臉書發文表示,只要把他前幾天文章的前因後果看完整,就不應該把他的話解讀成這樣。這場爭論的起點,是沈伯洋2014年的文章,當時沈寫道,如果台灣一時無法接受毒品除罪化,「至少可以效仿某些國家,建立社區中心,提供吸毒者毒品與乾淨的針頭,並導入社工機制予以協助」。

張景森說,他發文主要提到,把嚴重毒品成癮者從刑事犯罪問題,轉變成醫療、公共衛生與社會治理問題的思考,並不是沈伯洋在2014年憑空發明的,更不是什麼驚世駭俗的主張,而是歐洲很多國家早就發展出各種「減害」政策。

他說,1995年隨時任台北市長陳水扁訪問歐洲,就第一次接觸到荷蘭處理毒品、性產業等問題背後的減害治理思維。後來包括瑞士、德國、荷蘭、英國、丹麥、加拿大,也發展出不同形式的海洛因輔助治療,其中瑞士尤其值得研究。瑞士曾經面臨非常嚴重的毒品危機,後來逐步建立包括預防、治療、減害與執法在內的「四支柱」政策;對特定嚴重成癮、其他治療效果不佳的人,也在嚴格醫療監督下提供藥物治療,包括醫療級海洛因。他提到瑞士,主要是要回答蔣萬安的問題,世界上到底有沒有這種制度?答案是:有。這是不是「政府發毒品讓大家吸」?答案是:不是。

不過張景森強調,「瑞士有這種制度」與「沈伯洋當年主張的就是瑞士模式」,完全是兩件事。他從來沒有說過「沈伯洋主張的就是瑞士醫療用海洛因」。沈伯洋的主張,應該由沈自己說明,蔣萬安當然可以反對瑞士模式。也可以批評沈伯洋2014年的主張。甚至可以根據沈伯洋的文字,自己判斷他當時講的是不是瑞士這類制度,這些都可以辯論。但不應該把他沒說過的話塞到他的嘴巴裡,否則我們原來是在討論毒品政策,最後卻變成還要先花時間澄清,蔣萬安嘴裡的「張景森」,到底是不是張景森本人?

Open Questions

  • 沈伯洋對此爭議的正式回應為何?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by 自由时报.

Related Stories

National Day National Day aerial drill with full force debuts, incorporating elements of disaster prevention and social defense resilience
Politics·

National Day National Day aerial drill with full force debuts, incorporating elements of disaster prevention and social defense resilience

The National Day Parade rehearsal was held on the 6th in front of the Presidential Palace. This year, it incorporated elements of disaster prevention and social defense resilience. In addition to the police, firefighting and air service corps performing rescue operations, various military aircraft and the Thunder Tiger Group's Brave Eagle high-education aircraft also participated in the aerial exercise.

自由时报
2 min read
Communist spy Zhang Wanying was arrested for being involved with the prisoner Lai Qingde’s son. China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs responded
Developing·

Communist spy Zhang Wanying was arrested for being involved with the prisoner Lai Qingde’s son. China’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs responded

Zhang Wanying, a 34-year-old female housekeeper in California, was arrested on the 4th when she was about to fly to Shanghai on suspicion of being ordered by China to monitor Lai Qingde's son, Lai Tingyu. China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said it had no knowledge of the matter and opposed the smear campaign. The Presidential Palace thanked the United States for its assistance and the defendant has appeared in court.

自由时报
2 min read
The Lai Ruilun Na Masia Supporters Association was established and the Bunun name Tahai was given to them.
Politics·

The Lai Ruilun Na Masia Supporters Association was established and the Bunun name Tahai was given to them.

The Democratic Progressive Party's Kaohsiung mayoral candidate Lai Ruilong Namasha's support association was established. Honorary president Lin Guocai named him Tahai according to the Bunong tradition, symbolizing a brave warrior. Lai Ruilong thanked the tribesmen for their support and promised to promote the development of medical care, transportation and industry in his hometown.

自由时报
1 min read
Changhua Yuanlin Land Affairs and Household Affairs Joint Office Building has started construction and is expected to be completed in 2028
Politics·

Changhua Yuanlin Land Affairs and Household Affairs Joint Office Building has started construction and is expected to be completed in 2028

In order to improve service quality, the Changhua County Government raised 196 million yuan to build the "Yuanlin Land Affairs and Household Affairs Office Office Building" and held a groundbreaking ceremony on the 6th. It is expected that after completion in 2028, it will be able to serve a population of about 200,000 in the Taiyuanlin area, so that people do not have to travel between places to get business.

自由时报
2 min read
National Day preview CH-47SD hoists an 18-meter national flag and flies over Taipei accompanied by the national anthem
Politics·

National Day preview CH-47SD hoists an 18-meter national flag and flies over Taipei accompanied by the national anthem

The Double Ten National Day will kick off on Saturday, and the celebration organizer will hold a preview of the conference in front of the Presidential Palace on the afternoon of the 6th. The CH-47SD helicopter hoisted a huge national flag and accompanied the UH-60M to fly over the square in front of the Presidential Palace, creating a shocking scene.

自由时报
1 min read
Construction of social housing in Jingfeng 2nd District of Bei City starts today Jiang Wanan: The number of social housing in the city has reached 24,860
Politics·

Construction of social housing in Jingfeng 2nd District of Bei City starts today Jiang Wanan: The number of social housing in the city has reached 24,860

Construction of the Jingfeng Social Housing District II in Wenshan District, Taipei City, started today. It will provide 80 social housing units and fire station dormitories and other facilities. It is expected to be completed in 119 years. Taipei Mayor Chiang Wanan attended the groundbreaking ceremony and said that the total number of social housing units in Taipei City has reached 24,860, and residential construction will continue to be promoted.

自由时报
2 min read
More on this topic蔣萬安