BackPT questions, in court, Meta's alleged lack of political equality in the artificial creation of images of the two presidential candidates
PT questions, in court, Meta's alleged lack of political equality in the artificial creation of images of the two presidential candidates
Developing
G11 hour agoPolitics1 min readBrazilView original

PT questions, in court, Meta's alleged lack of political equality in the artificial creation of images of the two presidential candidates

Quick Look

Lula's coalition claims that WhatsApp's artificial intelligence tool refused to generate propaganda images with Lula's name and the number 13, while allowing similar requests for Flávio Bolsonaro and the number 22, and filed a representation with the TSE asking for the removal of restrictions and double compensation for the harmed reach.

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

During the 2022 Brazilian elections, digital platforms faced restrictions imposed by the TSE to prevent misuse of artificial intelligence in electoral propaganda, including a ban on generating images of candidates.

Font size

The coalition claims that it noticed the difference in treatment in WhatsApp's artificial intelligence tool on Tuesday night (13) and this Wednesday (14), in the morning, filed a representation with the TSE. According to Lula's campaign, the tool refused requests to create propaganda images with Lula's name and the number 13, but accepted requests with Flávio's name and the number 22. The document contains a list of different images linked to Flávio and the posts with the response from WhatsApp's AI stating that it could not create the same for Lula.

According to the lawyers, “not only does Meta block any generative interaction with artificial intelligence, stating ‘I was unable to generate the image you requested at the time’ or ‘this request involves content that I cannot generate according to Brazilian electoral regulations’, but, on the other hand, it generates images of electoral content in favor of Flávio Bolsonaro”.

In the document, the coalition asks the TSE to determine that Meta, owner of WhatsApp, removes any restrictions on the delivery of content by Lula and supporters, both in terms of content reach and the creation of propaganda images; and that the Goal compensates, double, the reach of publications that would have been harmed.

In a statement, Meta stated that, "in compliance with Brazil's electoral rules, it temporarily prohibited the recommendation of candidates or the generation of images of them; that additional measures were taken so that commands using only the candidates' first name and their number on the ballot do not produce images either."

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • The TSE may order the removal of selective restrictions and impose fines on Meta if it proves discrimination

    Possible · Within weeks

Open Questions

  • What specific criteria did Meta use to distinguish between requests from Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro?
  • Was the restriction applied uniformly to all candidates or just to some?
  • What was the exact reach of the publications affected according to the coalition?

Related Topics

This article was originally published by G1.

Related Stories

Senate Plenary discusses proposal on the end of the 6x1 scale
Developing·

Senate Plenary discusses proposal on the end of the 6x1 scale

The president of the Senate, Davi Alcolumbre, announced that the two shifts of the PEC that reduces the weekly working day from 44 to 40 hours will be voted on this Wednesday (14). The proposal, already approved in the Chamber and the Senate's CCJ, requires support from at least 49 senators in each vote due to the constitutional change. Alcolumbre highlighted that the reduction aims to protect workers' health, value family life and stimulate productivity, criticizing the politicization of the issue.

G1
2 min read
Lula supporters gather in a demonstration with the presence of Boulos at Praça Universitária, in Goiânia
Developing·

Lula supporters gather in a demonstration with the presence of Boulos at Praça Universitária, in Goiânia

The chief minister of the General Secretariat of the Presidency, Guilherme Boulos, participated in a demonstration of supporters of President Lula in Goiânia, at Praça Universitária, where he reinforced the president's messages about retirement, social rights and democracy, highlighting the importance of dialogue with voters from all political sides until the second round of elections on October 25th.

G1
2 min read
Senate begins voting on PEC that foresees the end of the 6x1 scale
Developing·

Senate begins voting on PEC that foresees the end of the 6x1 scale

The Senate rejected amendment 37 to the PEC to end the 6x1 scale, which sought to maintain weekly working hours of less than 40 hours for professions already regulated by law. President Davi Alcolumbre ended the first round and approved a request for voting in two rounds in the same session, with the support of senators from the Republicans and the Union. Senators such as Oriovisto Guimarães criticized the handling of the proposal, while Hamilton Mourão confirmed the opposing vote and Carlos Portinho and Flávio Bolsonaro declared support.

G1
1 min read
Senate prepares for decisive vote on the end of the 6x1 scale
Developing·

Senate prepares for decisive vote on the end of the 6x1 scale

The Senate rejected amendment 37 to the PEC to end the 6x1 scale, proposed by the PSDB, which sought to guarantee that professions with weekly working hours already established by law below 40 hours would not suffer additional reduction. The vote took place after approval of a request for a special calendar, allowing voting in two rounds in the same session. Senators such as Hamilton Mourão and Carlos Portinho expressed opposing and favorable positions, respectively, while Flávio Bolsonaro warned about possible economic impacts.

G1
1 min read
Senate should soon vote on PEC that foresees the end of the 6x1 scale
Developing·

Senate should soon vote on PEC that foresees the end of the 6x1 scale

The president of the Senate, Davi Alcolumbre, thanked senators Alan Rick and Jayme Campos for signing the request for a special calendar for voting on the PEC at the end of the 6x1 scale. Oriovisto Guimarães criticized the handling of the proposal and presented an amendment to exclude professions with weekly working hours of less than 40 hours already established by law. Hamilton Mourão will vote against, while Carlos Portinho and Flávio Bolsonaro will vote in favor. José Guimarães stated that the regulation will be carried out by complementary law, without compensation.

G1
1 min read
More on this topicsquid