Cancellation of Election Results and Transfer of Mayors in Türkiye Alleged Constitutional Crime
Quick Look
The author claims that the illegal implementation of the 2017 referendum and the transfer of mayors and deputies won by opposition parties after the 2023-2024 elections by the government are constitutional crimes and a regime coup, based on the will of the nation and the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms, which are the two pillars of legitimacy of the regime defined as a democratic, secular and social state of law according to the Constitution of the Republic of Turkey, and emphasizes that these actions reject the will of the nation and violate morality.
AI-generated summary
Why It Matters
The Constitution of the Republic of Türkiye defines the state as a democratic, secular and social state of law. The two foundations of legitimacy are the will of the nation (free, fair, transparent elections) and the protection of fundamental rights and freedoms (with independent judicial review).
Our Republican Regime is defined in our Constitution as a Democratic, Secular and Social State of Law.
This regime has two bases of legitimacy:
The first basis of legitimacy is that the source of power is the free, fair, transparent, periodic election results called "National Will" or "National Will".
The second basis of legitimacy is that all the actions and discourses of the elected government are in compliance with the "Fundamental Rights and Freedoms", especially the freedoms of expression (media, protest and opposition), and that this compliance is supervised by the independent judiciary (usually the Constitutional Court).
The current Government has stated through repeated practices and discourses that it does not comply with the decisions of the Constitutional Court and the ECHR, which are the second source of legitimacy and which the Constitution requires to be followed unconditionally.
It damaged the condition of free, fair, transparent and periodic elections, which is the primary source of legitimacy, by considering the votes cast against the law as valid during the so-called referendum of April 16, 2017.
***
After the 2023 and 2024 elections, the Government's TRANSFER of nearly a hundred mayors and around twenty deputies of the opposition parties that won the elections in which their own candidates lost, is a direct REGIME COUP AND A CONSTITUTIONAL CRIME:
Because with these transfers, the Government not only rejected the "Nation/People's support", that is, the "National Will" given to those elected people, but also changed it by turning it in its favor, contrary to what the voters wanted.
***
Of course, the attitudes and behaviors of the "elected people" who are subject to transfers and the "government that accepts them" also raise the question of morality:
Lying to and deceiving thousands or even millions of voters, including friends, close colleagues, and close friends, in order to be elected; thus violating both public and political morality, the election, the Democratic Regime and the Constitution!
***
Politicians of the Republic of Turkey, members of parliament, mayors, ministers, managers of the ruling and opposition parties, in short, all citizens, whether they are in politics or outside, are of course not such people:
In this column, I have repeatedly published the oaths taken by members of parliament and presidents:
Of course, those who take these oaths are moral, conscientious, reliable and loyal people.
In addition, I have repeatedly emphasized the general and legal morality of members of the judiciary and their commitment to the Republic of Türkiye, the Democratic Secular and Social State of Law.
Please do not take over municipalities through various methods, contrary to the election results.
Please stop and fix these transfers as well.
What to Watch
AI outlook — possibilities, not facts
The Constitutional Court may decide on the transfer of mayors and members of parliament by examining the applications.
Possible · Within months
Open Questions
- Whether these claims will be evaluated by the Constitutional Court or international courts
- Official statements of the transferred mayors and MPs regarding this situation
- The long-term impact of these practices on voter preferences







