Breaking
CNNo more Dome, Huida! Jiang Wanan suddenly issued a new policy to lower the threshold and increase the floor area ratio.ITStudents set fire to some bins in protest in VeronaCNNational League Championship Series" The rich Dodgers were swept by the Brewers. The coach lamented: He was suppressed by his opponents in all aspects.ITPlanes, delays and cancellations. Enav: “Anomalies on the data network”. Capacity halved. No hacker attackTRBREAKING NEWS... The funeral program for Dündar Ziya Gültekin has been announced! The funeral ceremony will be held today after Friday prayer.CNBlue and White strongly recommends exemption of health insurance premiums for those over 65 years old. The Supervisory and Protective Alliance criticizes "debts will leave children and grandchildren and destroy justice for generations."TRBREAKING NEWS! Cevdet Yılmaz: Our budget is focused on permanent prosperityCNConvicted of drugs and guns! 8 candidates in Nantou do not meet the qualifications and 1 has to apply for re-registration.CNThe National Town God Conference will appear on 10/17. Check the traffic control information around the Presidential Palace at onceITStock market: Europe opens in no particular order, we look at central banksCNNo more Dome, Huida! Jiang Wanan suddenly issued a new policy to lower the threshold and increase the floor area ratio.ITStudents set fire to some bins in protest in VeronaCNNational League Championship Series" The rich Dodgers were swept by the Brewers. The coach lamented: He was suppressed by his opponents in all aspects.ITPlanes, delays and cancellations. Enav: “Anomalies on the data network”. Capacity halved. No hacker attackTRBREAKING NEWS... The funeral program for Dündar Ziya Gültekin has been announced! The funeral ceremony will be held today after Friday prayer.CNBlue and White strongly recommends exemption of health insurance premiums for those over 65 years old. The Supervisory and Protective Alliance criticizes "debts will leave children and grandchildren and destroy justice for generations."TRBREAKING NEWS! Cevdet Yılmaz: Our budget is focused on permanent prosperityCNConvicted of drugs and guns! 8 candidates in Nantou do not meet the qualifications and 1 has to apply for re-registration.CNThe National Town God Conference will appear on 10/17. Check the traffic control information around the Presidential Palace at onceITStock market: Europe opens in no particular order, we look at central banks
Back【更新中】「検察なめんな」検事、被告人質問始まる 大阪地裁
【更新中】「検察なめんな」検事、被告人質問始まる 大阪地裁
Developing
朝日新聞2 hours agoLaw2 min readJapanView translation

【更新中】「検察なめんな」検事、被告人質問始まる 大阪地裁

Quick Look

大阪地検特捜部の取り調べで「検察なめんな」と怒鳴ったとして特別公務員暴行陵虐罪に問われた現東京高検検事の田渕大輔被告(54)の第6回公判が大阪地裁で開かれ、初めての被告人質問で取り調べの信条や検察官を目指した理由などを語った。

AI-generated summary

Why It Matters

田渕大輔被告は大阪地検特捜部の取り調べで被疑者に「検察なめんな」と怒鳴ったとして特別公務員暴行陵虐罪に問われている。現職の東京高検検事であり、今回の第6回公判で初めて被告人質問が行われた。

Font size

大阪地検特捜部の取り調べで「検察なめんな」と怒鳴ったなどとして、特別公務員暴行陵虐罪に問われた検事、田渕大輔被告(54)=現東京高検=の第6回公判は16日午前10時、大阪地裁で始まりました。この日は初めての被告人質問があります。現役検事として証言台に立った被告は、何を語るのか。主なやりとりをお伝えします。

10:00 開廷

裁判長が開廷を告げ、前回公判の証拠調べが再開された。

10:20 「事実を認め、話す決意をしたという調書にしたい」

田渕被告が不動産会社の部長だった男性を取り調べる様子を録画した映像の音声が法廷に流れた。

田渕被告は男性に対し、「事実を認め、話す決意をしたという調書にしたい。そういうトーンにしていきたい」「つっかかるものが完全に解消されていないと思っているが、そこは一緒に協力して頑張っていきたい」などと淡々と語りかけていた。

11:15 被告人質問始まる

被告人質問が始まった。弁護人が質問に立ち、まずは経歴の確認から。

弁護人 「司法試験を目指そうとした理由は」

被告 「高校時代に進路を父に相談し、『文系であるなら弁護士を目指してはどうか』と言われたのをきっかけに志望した」

弁護人 「検察官を選択した理由は」

被告 「お金や損得勘定に左右されず、素朴な正義感を胸に仕事ができるという点が大きかったと思います」

11:25 取り調べの信条は「相手を尊重し言い分を聞くこと」

弁護人 「検事になってから何人くらい取り調べたか」

被告 「正確な数は覚えていませんが、数百人単位の被疑者や参考人の取り調べをしてきたと思います」

弁護人 「取り調べとはどういうものですか」

被告 「取り調べたい対象者から事実を明らかにする供述を引き出す捜査活動。そういう風に思っておりました」

弁護人 「取り調べを行う上で、何か信条はありますか」

被告 「検察官と被疑者の立場の違いはありますが、できるだけ同じ人間として向き合うこと、相手を尊重すること、言い分をよく聞くこと。相手の人となりをよく知る。こういったところに気を使っていたという意識です」

12:00 「不合理な供述を続ければ厳しい追及」

問題となった業務上横領事件の捜査状況についての問いに入った。

弁護人 「本格的に事件(捜査)に関わるようになったのは」

被告 「2019年11月下旬ごろ」

弁護人 「(不動産会社部長だった男性は)貸し付けの流れなどを把握しており、重要人物として認識していたのですか」

被告 「はい」

弁護人 「(男性の逮捕前に)任意の取り調べはしましたか」

被告 「2回くらいありました。否認でした」

弁護人 「任意の調べで厳しい追及はしましたか」

被告 「私が考える厳しい追及はしていません。まだ証拠も不十分でした。男性の弁解を丁寧に聞き、証拠との整合性や合理性を吟味し、男性が不合理な供述を続ければ証拠を示して、場合によっては厳しい追及をすることを考えていました」

12:15 休廷

公判は休廷に入った。

What to Watch

AI outlook — possibilities, not facts

  • 裁判所は被告の有罪または無罪を言い渡す

    Very likely · Within weeks

Open Questions

  • 被告の取り調べが実際に違法だったかどうかの最終的な判断はどうなるか
  • 今回の公判の結果が検察内部の取り調べ方針にどのような影響を与えるか

Related Topics

This article was originally published by 朝日新聞.

Related Stories

“Remote analysis” of smartphone information acquisition targets impending damage; cabinet approves bill to revise law
Developing·

“Remote analysis” of smartphone information acquisition targets impending damage; cabinet approves bill to revise law

On the 16th, the government approved a bill to revise the Police Duties Execution Act, which will enable police to remotely access criminals' smartphones and obtain information through ``remote analysis,'' in order to prevent criminal damage caused by anonymous and mobile criminal groups. The law requires permission from a judge and requires the crime to be serious and it would be extremely difficult to collect information by other means. If passed, it is expected to be implemented as early as next year. Diet deliberations are expected to include discussions from the perspective of communication secrecy and privacy protection.

朝日新聞
2 min read
Governor Saito and others ``equivalent to non-prosecution'' due to leak of private information by Hyogo prefecture executives
Law·

Governor Saito and others ``equivalent to non-prosecution'' due to leak of private information by Hyogo prefecture executives

Regarding the case in which Hyogo Prefecture Governor Motohiko Saito and others were accused of violating the Local Public Service Act, and the Kobe District Public Prosecutors Office did not indict them, the Kobe Second Public Prosecution Committee announced a resolution stating that the non-prosecution decision was "appropriate." The accuser, Professor Hiroyuki Kamiwaki, has expressed that he is not convinced.

朝日新聞
2 min read
[Updating] “I’m sorry for the prosecution” Prosecutor questions the defendant “With a simple sense of justice in my heart”
Developing·

[Updating] “I’m sorry for the prosecution” Prosecutor questions the defendant “With a simple sense of justice in my heart”

The sixth trial of Daisuke Tabuchi (54), the current prosecutor of the Tokyo High Public Prosecutors Office, who was accused of assaulting and abusing a special public servant for yelling, ``I don't care for the prosecution,'' during an interrogation by the Osaka District Public Prosecutors Office's Special Investigation Department, began at 10 a.m. on the 16th at the Osaka District Court, during which the defendant spoke about his beliefs and past history during questioning.

朝日新聞
3 min read
Will the government accept responsibility for the nuclear power plant accident? What are the new claims from the residents? Ruling on the 16th
Developing·

Will the government accept responsibility for the nuclear power plant accident? What are the new claims from the residents? Ruling on the 16th

The Sendai High Court will hand down the judgment of the appeal court in the Tsushima lawsuit following the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant accident on the 16th. The plaintiffs, approximately 600 residents of the Tsushima district of Namie Town, are suing the national government and TEPCO for restoration of the original condition and compensation for damages. Although the Supreme Court denied the state's responsibility in 2022, new issues have been raised, and attention is focused on reviewing the judicial decision.

朝日新聞
2 min read
[Comprehensive understanding] Smartphone “remote analysis” bill Why is it being discussed now?
Developing·

[Comprehensive understanding] Smartphone “remote analysis” bill Why is it being discussed now?

The National Police Agency has announced a policy to introduce ``remote analysis,'' a method of obtaining information by remotely intruding into criminals' smartphones, in order to prevent the spread of damage such as special fraud and robbery and murder by anonymous and mobile criminal groups. A bill to revise the Police Officer Duties Execution Act has been approved by the Cabinet and will be debated in the Diet. The amount of damage will reach an all-time high of approximately 325.7 billion yen in 2025, and the aim is to overcome the situation where it is difficult to identify the instructor through cooperation from telecommunications carriers and analysis of seized devices.

朝日新聞
2 min read
More on this topic田渕大輔